Book Formatting

Reedsy Review: Is It Worth It for Self-Publishers?

Reedsy Review [2023] - READ THIS Before You Use Them!

Book a free 25-minute call. Tell me where your book is now.

Table of Contents

Reedsy is a good option if you want vetted editors and designers in one place and you are happy to pay for that, but think twice before spending that much on your first book. If you want more flexibility, Upwork gives you more room, and you can do a lot of the work yourself. I also design covers and format books for authors, so I see both sides of this. Below is what Reedsy is, how it works, the pros and cons in one list, what to do right after you sign up, and when hiring someone directly is the better call. This is the written version of my Reedsy review video, updated for 2026.

What is Reedsy?

Reedsy is a marketplace that connects authors with professionals in the publishing industry. You browse the professionals for each part of your book project and pull the team together. Reedsy says it accepts only about 1% of freelancer applications. It also runs apps: Studio (a writing app), Learning (courses), Discovery (book reviews) and Prompts (Reedsy, 14-Nov-26).

Who can use Reedsy?

It is mainly for authors who want to self-publish, plus the professionals who sell services there: editors, designers, marketers, publicists, ghostwriters, web designers and translators. The difference from Fiverr and Upwork is that those platforms have people from all walks of life, with no vetting beyond reviews. If you hire an editor on an open marketplace, you may go through many who are not vetted. If you would like a written report on your draft before you hire anyone, my manuscript review gives you one.

Reedsy also offers free tools. Its writing app Studio has core writing and formatting features that are free, and it exports EPUB and print-ready PDF. Paid plans add extras: Studio Essential is $4.99 a month and Outlining is $7.99 a month (Reedsy Studio). My top pick for formatting is Atticus.

What makes Reedsy different?

  • Vetted professionals. I have hired on open platforms and been burned by people without the core skill. A client of mine used an editor from another marketplace who wrote back that everything was perfect. That is not what you pay an editor for.
  • Your own job post. You write your project requirements and professionals respond with quotes.
  • Collaboration tools. Files, messaging and payments in one place, with a project protection guarantee.
  • Free guides and tools to help with the process.

How many professionals are on Reedsy?

Its home page lists 2,760 editors, 1,009 designers, 262 ghostwriters, 233 translators, 88 web designers and 71 marketers (Reedsy, 14-Nov-26). Editors and designers are the deep pools. Marketers are few, which fits my point below that Reedsy gives little help with marketing. The page does not show fees or price ranges, so you only learn what a job costs when the quotes come in.

How do I get started with Reedsy?

Step 1: Sign up

Create a free account.

Step 2: Choose your job’s requirements

This step makes you clarify what you want. What kind of help does the book need?

Step 3: Select 1 to 5 freelancers

Browse profiles and pick up to five you think can do the job. It can take back and forth to find the right one.

Step 4: Provide the job description

It is not a one-way street. The professionals decide whether to work with you and your book, and they can be selective.

Step 5: Negotiate

When the quotes come in, compare them and negotiate on price to make sure it is fair. For a sense of what the rates should be, see the 2026 figures in how to hire a professional book editor.

What are the pros and cons of Reedsy?

Pros

  • Vetted professionals. Reedsy says it accepts only about 1% of freelancer applications.
  • You can build a package from several services in one place.
  • Messaging, files and payments sit in one place, and Reedsy says projects are covered by its project protection guarantee.
  • Free quotes, and a free writing app with EPUB and print-ready PDF export.

Cons

  • Cost. It is expensive. I like to learn to do things myself first, then reinvest what the books earn into a team.
  • No prices up front. Reedsy’s home page shows no fees or price ranges, so you only learn the cost when the quotes arrive.
  • Limited control. The process is set up in a certain way, and you cannot mix and match everything.
  • Little marketing support. Only 71 marketers are listed against thousands of editors and designers, and I prefer Amazon for marketing. See Amazon ads for authors.
  • Competition. Many freelancers and authors use it, and finding the right person can take effort.

I just signed up for Reedsy. What now?

Do these in order, and spend nothing until the last step:

  1. Decide the one job you need first. Most first-time authors need an editor or a cover designer, not a whole team.
  2. Write the job post with your genre, word count, the finished state of the manuscript and your deadline. The clearer it is, the more useful the quotes will be.
  3. Ask up to five professionals for quotes, and read their profiles and samples before you do.
  4. Compare the quotes with real rates. The 2026 figures in how to hire a professional book editor show what a fair price looks like.
  5. Pay only when you are happy with the person and the scope.

When should I hire directly instead?

Hire direct, or through an open marketplace like Upwork, when you already know who you want, when your budget is tight, or when your book is simple enough that you can check the work yourself. Look at each person’s reviews and samples, and ask for a short paid test before you commit. Use Reedsy when you want the vetting done for you and the cost is fine for the book.

Is Reedsy right for you?

It depends. If you need the most flexibility, go with Upwork and check each person’s reviews and samples. If you want a lot of vetted professionals in one place, Reedsy saves time. Do not assume any marketplace is all professionals, and an open one can waste your money on amateurs.

You can also do it yourself. The goal of your first book is not a million sales but to learn the process and the ropes of getting a book onto the market, and some of your first books will not sell, so keep your costs low. My self-publishing cost calculator adds up what each job could cost you. Read myths about success in self-publishing, and if you want to format it yourself, see Atticus or Reedsy Studio.

Have you tried Reedsy? Tell me in the comments how it went. Not sure whether to hire help yet, or who to hire for your cover, editing or formatting? Book a free 25-minute discovery call and I will point you in the right direction. If it turns out you want the work done for you, I do cover design and formatting too.

Frequently asked questions

Is Reedsy free to use?

Signing up and requesting quotes is free, and its Studio writing app has free core features. You pay the professional you hire. Studio has paid plans from $4.99 a month for extras.

Is Reedsy better than Upwork?

It depends on what you need. Reedsy vets its freelancers and bundles messaging and payments, while Upwork gives more choice and flexibility, but you must screen people yourself and check their reviews.

Does Reedsy show prices up front?

Not on its home page. You post a job and request free quotes, and the professionals send tailored quotes for your book.

Do I need Reedsy to self-publish my first book?

No. You can do the formatting yourself and hire only what you need. The goal of your first book is to learn the process, so keep spending low.

Chris Baird

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.

Newest posts

Tags

Start with the free checklist

The 12 steps I follow for every book I publish. It is free, and you get it straight away.

You get the free checklist and Chris's emails. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.