Book Distribution

Vanity Press: What it Is & How To Avoid Publishing Scams

Chris Baird with a hand on his chin next to the words Vanity Press?, with bookshelves behind

Get the free publisher check: the questions to ask before you pay a publishing company.

Table of Contents

A vanity press is a company where you pay for almost every part of your book, and for almost every author self-publishing is the better choice. Some vanity publishers do get your book on the market, but you pay several thousand dollars up front and often give up royalties and control. Below are the models compared, the red flags and the pros and cons.

What is vanity publishing?

Vanity publishing is a model where the author pays a company to produce almost every aspect of the book: editing, cover, blurb and the rest. You keep some say over content, design and some marketing. The attraction is that the company takes the burden, so it replaces the time you would spend learning the skills I teach with one-and-done service. The challenge is the cost.

How do hybrid, vanity and self-publishing differ?

TopicVanityHybridSelf-publishing
Who does the workThe companyShared; you can take parts yourselfYou, plus freelancers you hire
Who paysYou, several thousand dollars up frontYou and the publisher share costsYou, at the lowest cost
RoyaltiesOften shared or reducedMay be splitYou keep them
ControlSomeMore inputFull
Time from youLeastSomeMost

A genuine hybrid publisher meets criteria such as screening submissions instead of accepting everything, publishing under its own imprint and ISBNs, providing distribution and paying higher-than-standard royalties (ALLi on the IBPA criteria, 7-Sep-22). Many vanity presses now call themselves hybrid, so check. See red flags with hybrid publishing companies.

Why do people fall for vanity publishing scams?

  • Not knowing the process. It all looks complicated.
  • A wish to be told they are a real author. The sales call says your book is wonderful.
  • Fear of rejection from traditional publishers.
  • Hope of huge sales. Sales pages are full of success stories.
  • Emotional pressure. The salesperson is warm until the money is paid.

What are the publishing company red flags?

They want money and royalties

If you pay thousands and the company also keeps a share of the royalties, ask what exactly it does for the royalty. Writer Beware, sponsored by the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America, puts it this way: “Pay to play is pay to play” (Writer Beware, newest post 16-Oct-26). To check an offer you have in front of you, use my free publishing offer red flag checker.

Their book examples are limited

Ask for books they have published and look at their sales ranks and reviews. A company that only shows covers has little to prove. My free publisher check puts the questions to ask about price, rights, royalties and your own accounts on one page.

Reading fees

The Authors Guild says legitimate publishers and agents do not charge authors to read their work (Authors Guild, 2-Apr-26).

Big promises

Be wary of guaranteed best-seller status, guaranteed sales or promises of huge results in exchange for large fees. The Authors Guild warns about companies that “make false promises to actively market your book and generate huge sales in exchange for an exorbitant fee” (Authors Guild, 2-Apr-26). The FTC alleged in April 2026 that Publishing.com misled buyers of self-publishing programs about the income they could earn and attached conditions to its refund guarantee (FTC, 13-Apr-26). My post on 3 self-publishing scams to watch out for covers best-seller tricks in detail.

“You’ll make your money back on book sales”

Most books sell little at first, and the typical self-published author earns modestly. If a company says your sales will pay back your fees, ask them to show you authors for whom that happened.

The ownership is unclear

Who owns the book? I have had clients whose book was published by someone else under their account, so they could not see sales or run ads and could not move it easily. Make sure the book is in your own KDP account.

What are the pros of vanity publishing?

  • Some creative control, since they do not dictate everything the way traditional publishers can.
  • Faster publication, if you want the project done fast.
  • Possibly better optimization, if you have not researched your market and your cover is weak.
  • Wider access, since some have a network for distribution (you can also do that yourself).

If you are not technical and you have the cash, vanity publishing may suit you.

What are the cons?

  • High cost. Thousands of dollars to start, then upsells on premium services and ads.
  • Limited distribution and marketing. If the book does not sell, they sell you marketing and not the advice to write more books.
  • Poor quality. Some outsource everything.
  • Reputation risk. Your book carries their name on the copyright page.

Do not go with a vanity publisher until you have spoken to a client who has done at least two books with them. People in the middle of the process are often still happy, since the company keeps you happy until the book hits the market. Groups of happy repeat authors seem hard to find. I applied this test to one well-known name in is Pegasus a vanity publisher.

Conclusion

For almost every author, self-publishing is the better choice. I have worked with people in their 80s and 90s step by step, click by click, and they were glad they did it. If you do not feel the energy to do it alone, you do not need to pay a vanity house thousands. Book a free 25-minute discovery call and we will work out the simplest way to get your book out. If you still choose a vanity publisher, pick one where multiple authors you can contact vouch for it.

Before you pay anyone, read what a vanity publisher is.

Frequently asked questions

What is a vanity press?

A company where the author pays for most or all of the production of the book, and often gives up royalties or control. In a vanity press the author is the main customer, not the reader.

Is a reading fee normal?

No. The Authors Guild says legitimate publishers and agents do not charge fees to read your manuscript.

How is vanity publishing different from hybrid publishing?

A genuine hybrid publisher screens submissions, publishes under its own imprint and ISBNs, provides distribution and pays higher-than-standard royalties (IBPA criteria). Many vanity presses now use the hybrid label, so check the criteria.

Chris Baird

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.

Newest posts

Tags

Start with the free checklist

The 12 steps I follow for every book I publish. It is free, and you get it straight away.

You get the free checklist and Chris's emails. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy

Before you pay a publishing company: the questions to ask

A free 2-page PDF of the questions to ask about price, rights, royalties and your own accounts, so you know the answers before you sign.

Get the free questions

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.