Book Distribution

Worst Self-Publishing Companies You Need to Avoid

Chris Baird pointing at the camera beside the word Worst? on a red banner

Get the free publisher check: the questions to ask before you pay a publishing company.

Table of Contents

The worst self-publishing companies are vanity presses pretending to be traditional publishers, fake literary agents who charge for a book deal, overpriced packages, marketing add-ons that sell nothing and contests you pay to enter. The clearest sign of all is being asked to pay before you have a contract you understand. Below are the warning signs to check before you pay, each type of company to avoid, and where to look a company up. For the options worth using, see the best self-publishing companies.

Which self-publishing companies are the worst?

The worst ones are the companies that take a lot of your money up front and give you little or nothing you couldn’t do yourself. I don’t give my own verdicts on named companies, but I do point to what Writer Beware, ALLi and the courts have said, and the companies share the patterns below.

A good first check is to search the company name together with the words “Writer Beware”. Writer Beware, sponsored by the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America, has posted warnings about vanity presses and fake agents for many years. The Alliance of Independent Authors (ALLi) also publishes ratings of self-publishing services, with labels from Excellent and Recommended down to Caution, Mixed and Watchdog Advisory. ALLi says the ratings are the informed opinion of its Watchdog Desk, and the page shows no date for them, so use a rating as a place to start, not as the last word.

What are the warning signs before you pay?

Check these before you send money to any company:

  1. You are asked to pay before you have a contract you understand, and it is called a loan, a package, a fee or a “distribution agreement”.
  2. The company contacted you first, and the message is full of praise for your book.
  3. You can’t see your own sales whenever you want, because the book is not in your own KDP and IngramSpark accounts.
  4. The price keeps growing: first a package, then marketing, then awards, copyright “proof” or insurance.
  5. You can’t find authors who have published more than one book with the company and are happy about it.
  6. A search for the company name brings up a Writer Beware post or an ALLi Caution, Mixed or Watchdog Advisory rating.

If you want the questions to ask in one place, the free publisher check is a 2-page PDF you can use before you pay. If you already have an offer, my free publishing offer red flag checker takes you through 18 questions and gives you the ones to send back.

What you are offeredThe warning signWhere to check
A “traditional” deal where you payMoney goes from you to themWriter Beware, your own contract check
An agent who wants a feeReal agents are paid after a saleAgent’s list of real deals
A package of thousands of dollarsServices you could buy one at a timeAuthors with several books at the company
Marketing, awards or “distribution” extrasEach one needs another paymentYour own sales dashboard
Praise by email out of the blueFlattery, then a request for moneyWriter Beware’s scam email posts

Two real cases show why. Writer Beware reported on 16-Oct-26 that an Australian children’s publisher required authors to give a “temporary loan” of AU$6,000, as “a condition of publication”, and its verdict is “pay to play is pay to play” (Writer Beware: Starfish Bay Publishing). And on 18-Sep-26 it reported that an author who invested nearly $50,000 with Wiley Book Writers, including “distribution agreements”, received a $3,000 wire and 50 hardcover copies, and that a US court entered judgments against the defendants (Writer Beware: Love v. Wiley Book Writers). The post notes that collecting on the judgments is the hard part.

What is a vanity press pretending to be a traditional publisher?

It is a company you pay to get your book on the market that presents itself as a traditional publisher. With a real traditional publisher, no money goes from you to them. They read lots of manuscripts, often through agents, pick the few they want, and pay you an advance. Then they pay for the editing, the cover design and everything else to give your book the best chance. You pay nothing.

A vanity press tricks you by saying it only selects a few of the very best authors. Its website looks professional, and it seems to turn most people away. It offers to review your book for free and tell you if you passed. You send it in, maybe they ask for a few changes, and then they tell you your book has been accepted. Of course, they don’t call themselves a vanity press. To see how I check one company’s claims, read my post on whether Austin Macauley is a vanity publisher.

Then comes the bill. Now you just have to pay them thousands of dollars to get the book on the market. You feel you were selected, that you won. In reality, they select almost everyone.

If you are wondering about any of them, find a Facebook group or forum where people who have used the company hang out. Look for authors who say it worked out and who have published several books with it. If you can’t find people like that, stay away.

I have no problem with paying for help as such. Just understand from the start that it will cost you a lot of money, and that you are paying for services, not being chosen.

Can a literary agent charge me to get a book deal?

No. Real agents are paid a commission only after they sell your book, so an agent who asks you for money up front is a warning sign. The scam is people who present themselves as agents with lots of contacts at publishing houses, and who say you just have to pay them.

Authors who pay these “agents” very rarely end up with a deal. The “agents” don’t have the connections. They may have helped one well-known author once, and they use that name with everyone.

A real agent can show you the deals they have made. If they can’t, I would not pay them anything. Talk to people in a forum who have worked with the agent for years and on several books. And watch for an “agent” who sends you on to a vanity press, so you pay twice for a company you had never heard of and nobody online talks about.

Are premium self-publishing packages worth the price?

Usually not, when they are grossly overpriced. You can pay freelancers on sites like Fiverr and Upwork a modest amount for single jobs. If you are paying many thousands of dollars to get one book through, I don’t recommend it.

You don’t have to pay anybody to do the whole thing. You get the software, you go through the steps, you figure it out, and then you can do it yourself. The same goes for ordering covers. If you are not sure which jobs are worth paying for, book a free 25-minute discovery call. Tell me where your book is now, and you leave the call with a clear next step, without the big bill. So many people regret the expensive route afterwards.

If you are considering a high-end package, talk to people who have used it for several books and say it was a great experience each time. If you can’t find them, that is a red flag. Some of these companies do a fine job, but you should be able to find several authors who used the same service for more than one book.

People rarely complain about the work itself. What they complain about is that after paying for every book service and marketing service, they aren’t getting any sales, and they are thousands of dollars down.

If you want a few of those jobs done without a package, they come one at a time: publication under an imprint with an ISBN and barcode, a print-ready cover and, if you want it, a formatted interior. I do these at fixed prices on my publishing services page, and you keep every right and every royalty.

Do I need a paid marketing package?

No. Marketing packages that sound essential are a favourite of vanity presses. They get you in the door with a low price, and then every little thing needs another paid service. If this is your life’s work, they say, surely you want to give it every chance.

They offer things like sending your book out to thousands of Twitter (X) followers and Facebook groups. In my experience, most of these services do not get you any more sales at all, and that includes some of the gigs you’ll find on freelancer marketplaces.

Each package can cost hundreds or thousands of dollars. You’ll do better learning to run ads on a small budget and building an email list yourself. If your sales never cover what you spend on a package, that is how you know it was overpriced.

Are writing contests and awards worth paying for?

Not when no one has heard of the contest. I’m not saying you should never enter one. But if your target reader has never heard of an award, it won’t move the needle for your book.

Many of these contests charge a fee just to enter, and that is where the money is made. Then, surprise, you have a good chance of winning, because few people enter the small ones. The really big contests are different: people recognise them.

So be careful. If you can enter your book for free, go for it. If an award makes you feel good about your book and keeps you motivated, that has some value too. But paying a lot of money for contests and expecting sales from them is a mistake. Your time is better spent writing more books and on marketing that works, such as content marketing, paid ads and an email list that helps you get reviews.

If you are still weighing up your options, self-publishing: the best option for you covers the trade-offs.

How do some companies trap your book, your ISBN or your money?

Three tricks come up again and again in the books I see from clients, and the contract is where each one hides.

ISBN charges. Some companies charge a lot for an ISBN. Compare that with what your country’s official ISBN agency charges (in the United States that is Bowker, through myidentifiers.com), where buying a pack lowers the price per ISBN, and remember that official agencies are the only source of ISBNs. The free ISBN from KDP can only be used on KDP and the imprint shows as “Independently published”, but if your book is only going on Amazon it does the job, so a company charging you a large fee for an ISBN is overcharging for something you may not need. Whoever owns the ISBN is listed as the publisher of record.

Copyright hijacking. If the company publishes the book under its own publishing house, it can take control of the book even when the contract says you keep the copyright. I have worked with clients whose books were trapped this way. Releasing the book can cost hundreds of dollars for something that takes seconds, unpublishing it from Amazon. When it comes down, the reviews go with it and your republished edition starts from scratch. You also can’t simply republish while their edition is live, because the same book would be on Amazon twice. And while it is under their name, they get the sales reports and decide what to share with you.

Pressure to order books. Many of these companies push you to order copies “for friends and family” because it “increases your sales”. Ask why the book isn’t selling and the answer is to order more. Every order is income for them, and you can’t recoup the money. Some tie their “free” ISBNs to sending them lots of copies of your book.

What should I check in a publishing contract?

Check that you keep your rights, that the book is in your own accounts, and who the ISBN is registered to. Unethical contracts take away your rights to the book, or take a share of your royalties forever.

Worse, some companies publish the book under their own account and then tell you each month whether you earned anything. Every month the answer is no, and then they try to sell you another package. Ask to see the sales dashboard and they say the contract doesn’t let you see it. They send you whatever royalties are left after their cut, and suggest you buy their special marketing package to increase them. And the upselling starts again.

Before you sign anything, check three things:

  1. Do you keep the rights to your book, and can you cancel and take it back?
  2. Is the book published under your own KDP and IngramSpark accounts, so you can see the sales yourself?
  3. Is it clear who the ISBN is registered to, and what happens to it if you leave?

If any answer is no, I would walk away. A contract is a legal document, so if there is a lot of money or your rights at stake, have a lawyer read it first.

What if an agent or publisher contacts me first?

Treat it with suspicion. A real agent answers queries; they don’t cold-contact you with an offer. Writer Beware explained on 25-Sep-26 how personalised scam emails are built with generative AI (Writer Beware). It lists signs such as stock phrases like “I recently came across”, leftover template blanks or wrong names, and long friendly exchanges that avoid fees until late. If someone messages you first and then asks for money, treat it as a scam, and check the real company’s website for the person’s name.

Is it ever worth paying a self-publishing company?

Yes, there is nothing wrong with spending money on your self-publishing business, as long as you get something real for it. The problem is paying and getting nothing back: no sales, no knowledge of how it works, and no steps you can repeat for your next book.

To catch problems before they cost you, read the three steps for spotting self-publishing warning signs.

Have you fallen for any of these rip-offs, or something else? Let me know below in the comments.

Frequently asked questions

How do I check if a publishing company is a scam?

Search the company name together with Writer Beware, look it up in the Alliance of Independent Authors ratings, and ask authors who have used it for more than one book.

Should a literary agent ever charge me money up front?

No. A real agent is paid a commission after your book sells, so an agent who asks for money before that is a warning sign.

What are the warning signs of a self-publishing scam?

You are asked to pay before you have a contract you understand, the company contacts you first with flattery, you can't see your own sales, or you are told to buy extras like distribution deals, awards or insurance. Check the company name with Writer Beware and ALLi before you pay.

Is a vanity press the same as self-publishing?

No. With self-publishing you keep your rights and your accounts, and you pay only for the services you choose. A vanity press charges you a large fee and often keeps control of your book. See is Pegasus a vanity publisher for an example of how to check one.

Chris Baird

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.

Newest posts

Tags

Start with the free checklist

The 12 steps I follow for every book I publish. It is free, and you get it straight away.

You get the free checklist and Chris's emails. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy

Before you pay a publishing company: the questions to ask

A free 2-page PDF of the questions to ask about price, rights, royalties and your own accounts, so you know the answers before you sign.

Get the free questions

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.