Self-publishing vs traditional publishing: earnings calculator
Put the same book through two or three routes. You fill in the price and the royalty from your own offer, and you get what each route pays per copy, per year and in total, and the number of copies where one overtakes the other. Everything you type stays in your browser.
What this sum leaves out
- A publisher's editing, cover, printing, distribution and bookshop sales work. A self-published book has to buy or do each of those.
- Your time, and the rights and control each route gives you or takes.
- How many copies each route really sells. Nobody can promise that number, so the copies boxes start empty and the result is only as good as what you type.
- Tax, shipping, returns and exchange rates. The advance is counted as paid in full in year one. The agent's share is taken from the advance and the royalties.
KDP figures are for Amazon.com and come from KDP's own help pages (see the KDP royalty calculator). Authors Guild figures checked on 16-Nov-26. These are not what authors usually earn, and the page makes no claim about that.
Worked example
Say a publisher offers a $5,000 advance with a 15% agent, a $10 ebook paying 25% of net receipts (set at 60% of the price), and an $18 paperback paying 7.5% of the list price, and you expect 400 ebook and 600 paperback sales a year. That is $1,410 a year in royalties before the agent's 15%, and the advance earns out after 3,547 copies.
Self-published, with a $4.99 ebook (a 2 MB file) and a $14.99 paperback of 280 pages on KDP, the same 400 and 600 sales pay $4,090 a year before costs. With $1,000 of costs, self-publishing overtakes the traditional offer at about 1,284 copies. The copies are numbers you type in. Nobody can promise them, and the sum says nothing about how many you will sell.
Questions people ask
What royalty rate does a traditional publisher pay?
The Authors Guild says that "for adult trade books, the royalty rates tend to run around 10–12%, with the higher rates kicking in after a certain number of sales have been met." That is the Guild's description in its model contract notes, not a figure I measured, and your own offer may differ (Authors Guild model contract, section 5, checked on 16-Nov-26). Type the rates from your offer into the form.
What is the difference between a royalty on list price and on net receipts?
The Guild says that "authors receive approximately 40–50% lower royalties from net receipts compared to royalties paid on the book's list price at the same percentage." The form lets you choose the basis for each format, so an offer paid on net receipts is not read as one paid on list price (Authors Guild, checked on 16-Nov-26).
How much does a literary agent take?
The Authors Guild says "commissions on domestic book publishing and performance rights (motion picture, television and live stage rights) agreements are generally 15 percent of the gross amounts payable to the author" (Authors Guild guide to agency agreements, checked on 16-Nov-26). The agent box above takes the percentage in your own agreement.
More free tools: the self-publishing cost calculator, the book page count calculator, the KDP keyword box checker, the KDP book description formatter, the book editing cost calculator and the book readability checker. See all the free tools.
Before you pay anyone to publish your book
If a company has offered to publish your book for a fee, get the questions to ask them first. I've self-published 230 books and these are the ones I would want answered. It is a free 2-page PDF.
You get the free questions PDF and Chris's emails. One email, no double opt-in. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy
