Book Distribution

Ex Employee Warns Us About Amazon KDP

Chris Baird looking shocked beside an Amazon KDP logo, with the word Ex-Employee?

Book a free 25-minute call. Tell me where your book is now.

Yes, I still say put your books on Amazon, even after an ex-employee’s warnings about KDP. The audience and the trust there are far bigger than anywhere else, and most authors I talked to realized they would not make money without it. The rest of this post covers the concerns my clients raised and the alternatives, IngramSpark and Draft2Digital.

Why do authors ask whether to publish on Amazon at all?

Several of my clients over the years have asked me whether they should publish with Amazon, based on negative press they’ve read, and whether there are better options. They have their books and want to get them on the market, but without going through Amazon, KDP or Kindle Direct Publishing. They had heard about working conditions, about the algorithms that push content to readers, and about other content on Amazon they objected to.

In 2020 I read articles in which an ex-employee, and other Amazon staff, warned about how little control there was over the content being published on KDP and how loose the limits were on what counted as acceptable. My clients felt that if they couldn’t find an ethical place for their books, the books would never reach the market at all.

What are the alternatives to Amazon KDP?

IngramSpark and Draft2Digital are the two I suggest. IngramSpark says it specializes in paperbacks, hardcovers, ebooks and global distribution, and Draft2Digital says it distributes to major online retailers and hundreds of storefronts. But those audiences are not the same size. You just don’t have the same search engine full of people with their credit cards out and ready to buy. The level of trust people have in Amazon is massive, and authors who go only through other stores don’t have access to Amazon’s ads and author profiles. In my experience their books often end up being sold on Amazon anyway, and they lose control. For a closer comparison, read IngramSpark vs Amazon KDP and Confronting Jeff Bezos | Exposing Amazon KDP Monopoly.

Some clients tried selling directly from their own websites. That requires setting up a website, a payment gateway, and a way to deliver the books to the readers’ devices. If a reader has a Kindle, you need extra steps to get the book onto it. When somebody buys from Amazon, the book is immediately in their library. Many of my clients ended up frustrated.

Does the Amazon algorithm push bad content?

The ex-employee’s claim was that you could push almost anything onto the market through KDP, hate speech included, and that the algorithm was easy to game with the right keywords, good enough content and a good cover, the very skills I teach. KDP does have written rules today: its content guidelines say it does not sell content it determines is hate speech, promotes the abuse or sexual exploitation of children, contains pornography, glorifies rape or pedophilia or advocates terrorism, and KDP says it will reject or remove content that breaks those guidelines. The way I understand it, the algorithm watches how people respond on the site, like what you see on Facebook, and based on what a person clicks and buys, it shows them more of the same.

As I read it, Amazon wanted to be a platform where anyone could publish almost anything, as long as it met a quality standard, without judging what it was about. The algorithms made sure Amazon made as much money from the books as possible, whatever the company’s own views. I teach how the algorithm works so you understand it: see Breaking Down KDP Publishing “Algorithm”. When a person buys a book similar to yours, Amazon can group yours with the bestsellers. Those are methods anyone can use, and you’d be using them for something positive.

Should I put positive books on Amazon?

Yes, that is what I tell my clients. Unless you’re famous and a multi-billionaire, put your books on Amazon. You start pushing the positive side and teaching the algorithm that these books make sales. None of my clients wanted to publish dark, negative books. Every one of them is publishing self-help or stories your average reader wants to read.

As a new author, it’s not the time to protest and end up with no sales. It’s the time to build an audience and momentum, and then, in a profitable niche, the money starts to flow. You can use that money to give to causes that fight what you oppose, such as fake news or other content you object to. Many new writers decide to become activists and refuse to put their books where readers will buy them. I don’t understand that. Donating your time, energy and money is great, but why not also encourage as many sales as possible so your positive message reaches the world?

The royalties are also better than many authors expect: KDP pays 70% on ebooks priced from $2.99 to $12.99 on Amazon.com since 07-Jul-26 (KDP royalty options).

What if I do not want to use Amazon?

I’ll talk with you about how to get around that, with Draft2Digital and IngramSpark depending on your situation. I don’t recommend it, but I’m always willing to work out what is in your best interest. Most of the people I discussed this with realized they wouldn’t make money without Amazon, and a lot of them ended up publishing there and giving their earnings to causes they support. If you want to talk it through, book a free 25-minute discovery call. There is no commitment, and you walk away with a clear idea of your next steps.

Since 2020 I have seen some objectionable books taken down and Amazon enforcing more restrictive policies, though you can still find quite objectionable books. A short story is an easy first book to try, see Get Your Short Story Published On Amazon.

I believe every writer reading this can become a bestseller on Amazon. It takes persistence and dedication, and it won’t happen in a month or two, but the steps themselves are easy, and I’ll take you through them one at a time.

Do you have an ethical problem with selling your books on Amazon KDP? Write “yes” or “no” in the comments so I understand where you’re coming from.

Frequently asked questions

Should I publish on Amazon KDP if I disagree with how Amazon runs its business?

That is your call. My advice is yes for most authors, because without Amazon's readers most books do not earn enough to fund the causes the author cares about.

Does KDP allow hateful or offensive books?

No. Its content guidelines say KDP does not sell content it determines is hate speech, promotes the abuse or sexual exploitation of children, contains pornography, glorifies rape or pedophilia or advocates terrorism. It may also refuse other material it considers inappropriate or offensive.

Can I sell my books without Amazon?

Yes, through IngramSpark, Draft2Digital or your own website, but you then need to handle payments and delivery to readers' devices yourself and you reach fewer buyers. See IngramSpark vs Amazon KDP.

Chris Baird

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.

Newest posts

Tags

Start with the free checklist

The 12 steps I follow for every book I publish. It is free, and you get it straight away.

You get the free checklist and Chris's emails. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.