Mindset

Perfectionism vs. Self-Doubt for Self-Publishers

Chris Baird with a hand raised, with the word Self-Doubt?

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through one, Urgesta AS may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Read the affiliate disclosure.

Book a free 25-minute call. Tell me where your book is now.

Perfectionism is the feeling that everything must be perfect before you publish. Self-doubt is the feeling that you are not good enough to publish at all. Both keep your book off the market, and the second is often hiding behind the first. Below I show how to tell them apart and what to do about each.

What did perfectionism cost me?

When I first self-published I wanted everything right. I followed a template I had found and everything I had read, watched and heard. I learned I needed a lead magnet to get people onto an email list, so I wrote a second book, which outsold my main book when it sold by itself. Then I decided I needed a website before I could publish. My need for everything to be in place before launch caused a huge delay between writing the book and putting it on the market. I lost sales.

Once the book is on the market you start finding all the mistakes you have been making. Someone once commented that a book by a little-known author, in a niche that wasn’t hungry or underserved, had made two or three thousand sales at launch. I looked it up in KDSpy (an affiliate link, and you pay nothing extra) and the book’s rank was in the millions. Why would thousands of people buy a book by someone nobody knows? Most first books sell little at first. That disappoints, but it triggers a useful response: now I can see what to fix. Many of the things I give away for free here cost me thousands of dollars to learn, and I wrote about that in self-publishing is pain, but here’s how to do it.

What does perfectionism look like?

You wait for the perfect timing, the perfect editing, the perfect cover, the perfect description. You create new barriers: “I should wait until I’ve written the whole series” or “I need to learn more about marketing first.” Sometimes it sounds like “I don’t want to put garbage on the market.” We can lie to ourselves this way. In my case I did not expect the book to sell. I was just delaying.

What does self-doubt look like?

Self-doubt says “I’m not good enough, strong enough or smart enough.” It says my books are garbage and I’m not worthy of being a self-publisher. Do you feel deep down that you don’t have what it takes? Those are lies. You do. All you need is to keep self-publishing easy and to stick with it. I won’t tell you that you’ll publish and make millions of sales.

Don’t ever lie about your results, to others or to yourself. If you claim millions of sales you set up false expectations for other people. Lying to yourself is a huge problem too. If you have doubts, be honest: I don’t know if my books are good enough.

Authors I coach often feel it deep down, that they don’t have the technical skill or the quality. Others just want the book to be good because so much garbage is put out. Then they wait forever.

How good does the book need to be?

Get it out as fast as you can, then fix it. Some viewers push back on that. My test: if your book is getting 3 to 5 stars organically, it is good enough. If you put out poor work you will get 1 or 2 stars, and that is a learning experience. The goal is to produce things of value and put them in front of a market that wants them.

That makes a triple win. Amazon wins because it makes sales, you win because you make sales and write more books, and readers win because they get the value they were looking for. If you don’t get anything on the market, nobody wins.

It’s like a minimum viable product in business. YouTube’s founders have said the original idea was a video version of an online dating service. When they had trouble finding enough dating videos, they let people post any kind (Wikipedia). The market told them what it liked. It will tell you too, and that helps with your next book. If you keep asking whether to build skills or keep going, read skillset vs mindset in self-publishing.

Is your problem really self-doubt?

Here is what I see most often: the real problem is self-doubt disguised as perfectionism. Perfectionism is about the product being too low quality. Self-doubt is about you being low quality, so nothing you put out can give value. Self-doubt is the worse one. Both stop you publishing.

There are two ways past it. First, hear positive things from other people. On my channel and with my coaching clients I never say maybe you don’t have what it takes. As clients go through the steps, they see it is easy and they don’t need to do it the hard way. Second, go through the steps and publish. Even if the books are not perfect, they can go from good to great over time. That won’t happen if the books never get on the market.

If you think the quality is not good enough, remember readers can leave a low rating or return a book. Either way they tell you what to fix.

Is your problem perfectionism or self-doubt? Tell me in the comments. If you want a plan and someone in your corner, book a free 25-minute discovery call.

Frequently asked questions

How do I know if I am a perfectionist or have self-doubt?

Perfectionism says the product is not good enough yet. Self-doubt says you are not good enough. If you keep finding new things to fix before launch, ask yourself which one is talking.

Is it OK to publish a book that is not perfect?

Yes. Get the book out, see what readers say, and fix it. Readers can leave a low rating or return a book, and either way they tell you what to improve. See can you edit your ebook after it is published.

Will my first book be a bestseller?

Probably not. Most first books sell little. Learning what to fix from that first book is what builds the next one. See self-doubt as a self-publisher.

Chris Baird

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.

Newest posts

Tags

Start with the free checklist

The 12 steps I follow for every book I publish. It is free, and you get it straight away.

You get the free checklist and Chris's emails. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.