Mindset

How to Overcome Self-Doubt as a Self-Publisher

Chris Baird scratching the head beside a speech bubble, with the word Self-Doubt

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through one, Urgesta AS may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Read the affiliate disclosure.

Book a free 25-minute call. Tell me where your book is now.

To overcome self-doubt as a self-publisher, stop trying to make the book flawless and compare it with the books that are already selling in your category. My coaching client Gary was stuck re-editing his second book, afraid that publishing it early would make him look terrible. One look at a best seller changed that. Here is what we did.

What does self-doubt look like for an author?

Gary first contacted me by signing up for a free discovery call, where we looked at his books. He had published a first book but was not confident in it. His second book had been through round after round of editing. The goal was to make it perfect before releasing it. He kept asking himself, “If I put this out before it is ready, won’t it make me look terrible as an author?”

That is self-doubt in a very common form. The book sits in re-edit mode, and nobody gets to read it. If you also dread being asked whether you self-published, that is part of the same doubt. For more on this, see releasing a good vs. perfect book.

What did we find when we looked at the best sellers?

Gary writes about woodworking. In the call we pulled up the woodworking books on Amazon using KDSpy, the tool I use myself. We looked at the number two book in his category, and opened it. In the first chapter, the first two words had no space between them. A typo on page one.

The book was selling very well, going by the volume of sales coming through. Gary saw that a book does not have to be perfect to do well on Amazon. Is the number two author in woodworking terrible because of a typo? No. Their readers care about the value the book delivers. In fiction, does it excite them? In nonfiction, does it solve their problem? Readers are not sitting like an English teacher with a red pen.

Does that mean I should skip proofreading?

No. I still use Grammarly to catch grammar and spelling mistakes in a book, fix them and move on. The point is to stop at “good enough”. Good enough means the book makes sales, gives value and brings readers some joy.

What should I do with my earlier books?

Gary asked whether he should go back to his first book and fix things, such as the sales page and the layout. I said no. If a fix takes a few seconds, do it. He did not like the cover of his first book, but it looked very much like the covers of the best sellers in his market. If it is not selling, make the changes. Otherwise the goal is to keep putting books on the market and make each one better than the last. See optimize your Amazon book page for the sales page.

By the end of the call Gary decided that his second book was good enough and his first could stay as it was. He was eager to move on to formatting, and I saw a confidence in him that was not there before.

Is it normal to find marketing harder than writing?

Yes. In the Written Word Media 2025 indie author survey (published 2-Dec-25), well over 80% of the authors who answered named marketing as the most challenging part of being an author, harder than writing or production. These are self-reported answers, but they show you are not alone if the doubt is about what happens after you publish. A book that is out and finding its first readers teaches you more than a fourth round of edits.

What if the doubt is more than a writing problem?

Self-doubt is common, and it is not a diagnosis. The WashU health promotion page lists what helps: talking with others about it, noticing your inner critic and looking for a more balanced thought, acknowledging what you do well, trying new things and celebrating achievements (WashU Health Promotion). If it is affecting your sleep, work or daily life, talk to a doctor or counselor. I am a coach, not a clinician.

His book has something to give: how to do woodworking better. Going around and around on one book deprives readers of that. Yours may be the same. Also read how long should a self-published book be and my post on promoting your book with video.

Do you have a book sitting in re-edit mode? Book a free 25-minute discovery call and we will decide together whether it is ready.

Frequently asked questions

Is self-doubt normal for new authors?

Yes. A Washington University health promotion page describes this kind of doubt as common and not a diagnosis, and suggests talking about it, noticing your inner critic and taking action (WashU). If it is hurting your daily life, talk to a doctor or counselor.

How do I know my book is good enough to publish?

Compare it with the books at the top of your category, and check for the basics with a grammar tool. If it delivers what the title promises, publish, then read the reviews and improve.

Should I go back and improve my earlier books?

Only if they are not selling, or a fix takes a few seconds. Time on the next book usually brings more.

Chris Baird

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.

Newest posts

Tags

Start with the free checklist

The 12 steps I follow for every book I publish. It is free, and you get it straight away.

You get the free checklist and Chris's emails. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.