Mindset

Self-Publish vs Publisher: Know the Difference

A surprised Chris Baird shrugging beside the word Publisher?

Book a free 25-minute call. Tell me where your book is now.

Table of Contents

The main difference is control and money. Self-publishing gives you control of every step and most of the royalties, while a traditional publisher gives you an advance, a team and bookstore distribution, and keeps most of the profit. If your goal is to get a book on the market and earn from it, I think self-publishing is the better way. Below are the process, costs and drawbacks of each route, and how to choose. If you are wondering about one of the big names, I wrote about is Penguin Publishing worth it.

How does self-publishing work?

What is self-publishing?

You produce the book and put it on the market yourself, as ebook and print. You keep control over writing, editing, cover design, formatting and marketing. You don’t have to do every step yourself, since you can hire people, but you must find them, tell them what to do, check the quality and keep to the schedule. You also keep ownership of your work. With hybrid or traditional publishing, you may keep the copyright on paper but the book sits under their account, which can make it hard to get back, even when it makes no sales.

What is the process?

  1. Manuscript preparation. Editing, with the approach and budget up to you. You decide how much money, time and help goes into this phase.
  2. Design and formatting. You can format the book yourself; I recommend Atticus. Any tool brings some frustration at first, and you will need to invest time learning it.
  3. Distribution and marketing. You choose the distributors, and marketing is up to you. That is true with traditional publishing too: nobody else will move the needle for your book.

What are the pros and cons?

Benefits {#Benefits_of_Self-Publishing}

  • Creative control. Nobody tells you to cut a paragraph or change the cover. The downside is you can make wrong choices, so get input from experienced self-publishers or a coach.
  • Higher royalties. On Amazon.com you earn 70% on ebooks priced from $2.99 to $12.99 (KDP pricing, effective 7-Jul-26), and 50% or 60% of the list price on paperbacks, depending on price, minus printing costs (KDP paperback royalty).
  • Speed and flexibility. You decide how fast to move. Nobody pushes you, so a book can stall if you don’t put in the effort.

It is not easy, but it is manageable one step at a time.

Drawbacks {#Drawbacks_of_Self-Publishing}

  • Less guidance. No one tells you what to do. A coach can save time and frustration.
  • Fewer bookstore shelves. Your book will be in all the online stores, but local bookshops may not carry it.
  • Perception. Some people may think a self-published book must be poor. In my experience readers go on word of mouth, reviews and your description.

How does traditional publishing work?

What is traditional publishing?

You submit a manuscript to publishing houses, which select the works they think will sell. They pay for editing, cover design, printing, distribution and some marketing, bear the risk, and may pay an advance against royalties. You usually need a literary agent to reach them.

What is the process?

  1. Find an agent, who gives feedback on the book and how to position it.
  2. The agent submits to publishers with whom they have connections.
  3. Negotiate the contract. Many authors are so excited to sign that they don’t check how bad a deal it is. Have a lawyer with experience of publishing contracts review it.

What are the pros and cons?

Benefits {#Benefits_of_Going_with_a_Traditional_Publisher}

  • Expertise and a team that takes the book through production.
  • Distribution to bookstores, which matters if you want to see the book on a shelf.
  • Credibility and prestige, since you have passed the gatekeepers.

Drawbacks {#Drawbacks_of_Traditional_Publishing}

  • Less control. They can ask for changes to the title, cover and text.
  • Time. It can take years to get to market.
  • Lower royalties. The Authors Guild describes standard ebook contracts as 25% of net receipts and the traditional hardcover royalty as 15% of list price (Authors Guild, 9-Jul-15). Royalties show you that readers care, and they motivate you to keep producing.

How do they compare?

TopicSelf-publishingTraditional publisher
ControlYou decide everythingThe publisher can change title, cover and text
Time to marketKDP says about 3 business days after you submit (KDP timelines)Often years, and you need an agent first
Ebook royalty70% on $2.99 to $12.99 on Amazon.comAbout 25% of net receipts
Upfront moneyYou pay for what you hireAn advance may be paid
BookstoresMostly onlineEstablished bookstore distribution
SupportYou buy it (freelancers, coaching)The publisher’s team

What should I consider?

Creative control versus support, time and speed, and money. If you self-publish you must invest time and money in finding the right people and managing them. Coaching can provide that guidance: my 1-on-1 coaching starts at $147 a month, with one, two or three 55-minute Zoom calls a month. Some authors tell me money does not matter to them, and many of them later find that it does. To see what each route pays on your own book, put your numbers into the free self-publishing vs traditional publishing earnings calculator.

Which famous authors went each way?

Self-published first {#Examples_of_Successful_Authors_Who_Have_Self-Published}

  • Andy Weir self-published The Martian, which I enjoyed.
  • E.L. James’s Fifty Shades of Grey started as online fan fiction and was first released by a small independent publisher before a major publisher picked it up.
  • Hugh Howey self-published his science fiction and remains a major voice in self-publishing.

Traditionally published {#Examples_of_Successful_Authors_Who_Have_Used_Traditional_Publishers}

  • J.K. Rowling’s Harry Potter books came out through Bloomsbury in the UK and Scholastic in the US, after rejections.
  • Stephen King’s first published novel, Carrie, was rejected many times before Doubleday published it.
  • Dan Brown’s The Da Vinci Code was published by Doubleday in 2003.

The lesson is persistence: gatekeepers may not recognize a good book at first. Ask yourself whether you want to go through that, and how many authors it did not work out for.

How do I decide?

Personal goals

If your goal is to get a book on the market, self-publishing is the best way. It also teaches you about online business and passive income. For your connections and business life, a traditionally published book carries weight. But the moment you make one sale to a stranger, you are an author, which most people who want to write a book never do.

Money

Traditional publishing needs a book that is already edited and polished and an agent. Self-publishing gives a greater return on your time and effort over the long run, because each sale funds ads for more sales. If you are in debt, you can do most steps yourself until the book starts earning. See how to self-publish with no money and how to write, publish and sell an ebook.

Control or support?

If you want control, self-publish. If you want support, many think traditional, but you can buy support too. My group coaching is $47 a month, cancel any time, with a private Slack group where you talk to other authors and get answers from me.

If you want to balance both, a hybrid or vanity publisher may look suitable, but verify the company first and talk to people who published at least two books through it and are satisfied. If you can’t find them, don’t proceed. See red flags with hybrid publishing companies. Many clients came to me after spending thousands on one.

Conclusion

Which option is best for you depends on your goals, money and wish for control. If you are still torn, book a free 25-minute discovery call. We look at where you are on Zoom and which path suits your book.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need an agent to get a traditional publishing deal?

In most cases yes. Large publishers rarely read manuscripts sent directly, so authors usually find a literary agent first, who then pitches the book.

What royalty does KDP pay compared with a traditional publisher?

KDP pays 70% on ebooks priced $2.99 to $12.99 on Amazon.com, and 50% or 60% of the list price minus printing costs on paperbacks. The Authors Guild describes standard traditional ebook royalties as 25% of net receipts and the traditional hardcover royalty as 15% of list price.

How long does it take to publish with KDP?

KDP says it takes about 3 business days for a new book to go live. Paperbacks can take up to 72 hours on Amazon.com and up to 5 days elsewhere, and first-time accounts can take up to 6 days.

Chris Baird

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.

Newest posts

Tags

Start with the free checklist

The 12 steps I follow for every book I publish. It is free, and you get it straight away.

You get the free checklist and Chris's emails. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.