Mindset

What Is a Vanity Publisher? Definition and Red Flags

Chris Baird with open hands beside the words Vanity Publisher? on a red circle

Get the free publisher check: the questions to ask before you pay a publishing company.

A vanity publisher is a company that charges the author to publish a book. It makes its money from the author’s fees and add-on services, not from selling the book to readers, and many also keep some of your rights or take a share of your sales. Self-publishing is different: you keep your rights, you pay only for the services you choose, and you set up your own accounts on Amazon KDP or IngramSpark. The rest of this post covers the red flags and the alternatives. If you want names, I list the worst self-publishing companies I would tell authors to avoid.

What does a vanity publisher do?

The author pays, and the company does the work: cover, title, keywords, description and distribution. Some take control of the rights to the book. The selfpublishing.com guide to vanity publishing (11-Dec-23; that site sells author services, so compare sources) defines it as charging authors to publish their book, also called subsidy publishing or vanity press. It contrasts it with self-publishing, where the author keeps the rights and most royalties, and with hybrid publishing, where authors also pay upfront but the publisher is supposed to be selective and meet higher quality standards. Hybrid is a gray area, so check how a hybrid publisher makes its money and whether it screens manuscripts. Many vanity companies now call themselves hybrid publishers or author services, so the label on the website tells you very little.

Why did I learn about this?

I wrote a thousand words a day to finish my first book, put it on Amazon, and sales were terrible. I went to podcasts, books, YouTube and courses. On some of them people said they paid others to do everything, including the cover, and gave away the rights. Their books ended up frozen and being milked for more money.

What are the red flags?

  1. You pay first. A package of $1,000 or $5,000 gets the book out, then each upsell is “a better cover”, “a better description”, “a marketing pack”.
  2. The contract takes your rights or ties up the book. Writer Beware warned on 9-Oct-26 about contracts with “sweeping claims on a large menu of rights” and “no provision for rights reversion.” On 16-Oct-26 it wrote about a publisher that called its AU$6,000 upfront fee a temporary loan, and said plainly: “Pay to play is pay to play.”
  3. You cannot get your files and cover back if you leave, or see your own sales.
  4. Fees for things you can do yourself, like uploading to Amazon.
  5. Flattery or a sales call within hours of first contact, and guaranteed store placement or media access.

You will find all of this in their terms, so they are usually not doing anything illegal. It is a bad deal. Getting your rights back can mean a legal fight. Before you sign, read the contract, and search the company name on Writer Beware and the Alliance of Independent Authors service ratings, run by its Watchdog Desk.

How do you check a publisher before you sign?

The Alliance of Independent Authors runs a Watchdog Desk, and its service ratings use six labels: Excellent (Partner), Recommended, Caution, Mixed, Watchdog Advisory and Pending. The page calls them the informed opinion of the Watchdog Desk. It does not publish a scoring method, so treat a rating as a starting point and read the contract yourself.

The page also says a listed company can dispute its rating and ask about the assessment process. That is useful to know if a salesperson waves a good rating at you. Ask for the contract in writing and read it before any call.

My advice: search the company name on both Writer Beware and the ALLi ratings, then ask them three questions in an email. Who owns the rights? Do the files and cover come back to me if I leave? Will the books sit in my own KDP and IngramSpark accounts? A straight answer in writing is a good sign. A vague answer, or a push to sign this week, is not.

Is vanity publishing the same as self-publishing?

No. People use “vanity” as a put-down, as if you are too vain to write a book a real publisher would pick up. Traditional publishers take very few books, and usually want proof of a quality book, a blog or a following. The term is not neutral, and many dislike it.

Self-publishing on KDP or IngramSpark means your own accounts and your own dashboard. IngramSpark says it costs nothing to sign up and upload, and I answer whether IngramSpark counts as a vanity publisher. Learn the steps, hire only the parts you need, and format with a tool like Atticus, which I recommend. You can fix a cover, a title or a description later. I have changed titles on many books and sold more. Here is how to read the KDP side: understanding the KDP Amazon self publishing dashboard.

Most of what a publishing package charges for comes down to a few jobs you can pay for one at a time: publication under an imprint with an ISBN and barcode, a print-ready cover and, if you want it, a formatted interior. I do these at fixed prices on my publishing services page, and you keep every right and every royalty.

When might a vanity publisher still make sense?

If you truly have no time or energy, it is your choice. Almost everyone I have heard of who went this way regretted it. In 99% of cases, a little time every day gets you through the process, and you keep control and more money. If a major publisher later wants your self-published book, you can sell them the rights. I explain why in is it better to self-publish a book.

Want to check a company you are considering? Book a free 25-minute discovery call and bring the contract. Have you had a good or bad experience? Tell me in the comments.

Frequently asked questions

What is a vanity publisher?

A company that charges the author to publish a book. It makes its money from the author's fees and add-on services, not from selling the book to readers.

What are the red flags of a vanity publisher?

You pay first, the contract takes your rights or ties up the book, you cannot get your files back or see your sales, you pay for things you can do yourself, and the sales pitch starts within hours.

Is vanity publishing the same as self-publishing?

No. In self-publishing you keep your rights, pay only for what you choose, and use your own accounts on Amazon KDP or IngramSpark.

How do I check a publisher?

Search the company name on Writer Beware and the Alliance of Independent Authors service ratings, and read the contract before you sign.

Chris Baird

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.

Newest posts

Tags

Start with the free checklist

The 12 steps I follow for every book I publish. It is free, and you get it straight away.

You get the free checklist and Chris's emails. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy

Before you pay a publishing company: the questions to ask

A free 2-page PDF of the questions to ask about price, rights, royalties and your own accounts, so you know the answers before you sign.

Get the free questions

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.