Mindset

The Mistake to Fix Now: Writing in Too Many Niches

If you don't fix this now, you'll hate yourself later!

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through one, Urgesta AS may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Read the affiliate disclosure.

Book a free 25-minute call. Tell me where your book is now.

The self-publishing mistake to fix now is writing books in many unrelated niches under one name. Choose one profitable market, give each niche its own pen name, and stay in it for years. I made this mistake myself, and it cost me readers, and here is what I learned.

What happens when I write in too many niches?

When I started I thought I should publish on whatever interested me. I did not even know what a “market” was. I built an email list from readers, which is a great idea, but my books were all over the place. How can you write to people who bought a puppy training book, a carpentry book and a survival book in the same emails? Someone interested in vegan cooking got a message about mowing the lawn. Many would unsubscribe.

It was chaos. I could not run ads, content marketing or email in a focused way. And readers asked: are you an expert on all of this, or are these just hobbies? An expert is someone you know, like and trust, who spends hours getting really good at one thing. A little of this and that blurs your name, and a new book gives no one a reason to buy because it is on a different topic every time.

What should I do instead?

Give each niche its own pen name. A name should be associated with one niche and one topic. KDP says you can use a pen name or pseudonym, and your real name stays anonymous on its site. You still enter your real name in your account so payments and tax forms are correct. After you publish, the primary author field cannot be changed without a new edition (KDP Authors & Contributors). More in pen names for authors.

What does KDP ask of a pen name?

Two things matter. The pen name should stay consistent across all the books you publish under it, so readers find your catalog in one place. And KDP says that after you publish it may ask for a copy of the rights to your book, so keep your contracts and cover and image licences in one folder (KDP Authors & Contributors). A pen name is a branding choice, not a way to hide who owns the book. Whether KDP lets you publish under a pen name is answered in using a pen name on KDP.

How do I choose the right market?

I read a book called Choose, whose point was that choosing the wrong market costs you big in the long run. A market is your niche or genre, the keywords people search, and where you can be the expert. Problems to avoid:

  • A niche nobody is searching for, with no books on Amazon, so you cannot tell whether anyone will buy.
  • A niche with too many books, where yours gets lost.
  • A fad. If you had written a book on fidget spinners in 2017 you might have sold a lot of copies, and in 2018 not so many.

I use KDSpy to check whether a niche is already profitable: there are books, but not too many, and the ones there sell. When I write into one of those underserved markets, the books sell far better than in a random one. The method is in what is a winning topic for your first ebook.

How long should I stay in one niche?

For years. In my experience it takes three to five years of continuous writing, ads and email, and a new book in the same niche every year, so that people associate your name with those books. Your readers tell you what they like, and you write the next book to match.

Many people give up after a couple of months or years, just before their break, and start a new niche. That means reinventing yourself and starting from the beginning, then reaching the same frustration. Pick something you enjoy and could imagine writing about ten years from now. The story of what I would do differently is in what I’d do if I had to start over.

I think of it as currents in the ocean. We are not inventing readers. We find them where they already are, like the Gulf Stream that pulls ships north toward Norway, where I live, and we align our sails with that current in an area with few ships.

If you have not chosen a niche you can stay in for years, book my free 25-minute discovery call and we will look at your books and pick one together.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use more than one pen name on KDP?

KDP says you can use a pen name or pseudonym, and your real name stays anonymous on its site. You should still enter your real name in your KDP account information so payments and tax forms are right (KDP Authors & Contributors). See my post on pen names for authors.

Can I change the author name after I publish?

Not on the same book. KDP says you cannot change the primary author field after publishing, but you can create a new edition with the corrected name (KDP Authors & Contributors). Choose the name before you publish.

Is it a mistake to chase a trending topic?

It can be. A fad can sell for a short time, like fidget spinner books in 2017, and then fade. I prefer a niche with steady demand that I could write about for ten years.

Can KDP ask me to prove I own the rights to a pen name book?

Yes. KDP says that after you publish, it may ask for a copy of the rights to your book, and it wants the author name to stay consistent across your books (KDP help).

Chris Baird

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.

Newest posts

Tags

Start with the free checklist

The 12 steps I follow for every book I publish. It is free, and you get it straight away.

You get the free checklist and Chris's emails. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.