Book a free 25-minute call. Tell me where your book is now.
Yes, a self-published book can succeed, but most authors fail, and the reason has nothing to do with talent. They stop learning, stop executing, or try once and give up. This post covers what the numbers say, what I learned from a can of basil and a broken mustard bottle, and why comparison is the one mistake that guarantees failure.
Can a self-published book really succeed?
Yes. Full-time self-published authors had a median income of $12,800 from their books in 2022 ($15,000 counting other author-related work), according to the Authors Guild’s 2023 income survey of 5,699 published authors. That is a median, so half earned less, which fits what I see: most authors do not get there. The ones who do keep going and keep improving their books.
What did a can of basil teach me about not giving up?
My son brought home a school project: a soup can with the label removed, soil inside, and a seed we couldn’t identify. The assignment was to water it and give it sunlight. It grew into an Asian basil. We know nothing about plants, and every plant we have owned has died, mostly because we travel a lot.
The basil did well, and I even put watering in my task manager. Then came a one- or two-week trip. How do you keep a plant alive while you’re away? I tried a self-watering spike, which over-watered. A bulb device over-watered. Coke bottles with holes in the bottom over-watered. A YouTube video showed a bottle with a string running up into the plant, which worked, though it kept falling over. Finally I found a pot that waters itself.
Then I thought, why stop at one? We now have 12 herbs growing in self-watering pots. My son’s mystery seed became a brand new hobby. The lesson is that failures drive success if you don’t give up. I had given up on plants too many times because I did not have the right strategy. Books are the same. My first book sold only now and then because I put it in the wrong market, and I kept going anyway.
Why do most self-published authors fail?
Most authors fail for one of two reasons. They stop learning, or they stop executing. Execute without learning and you repeat the same mistakes, like us killing plants over and over. Learn without executing and you never put the strategies into action. The third camp, probably the most common, tries once, fails and gives up, then hops to something else.
I tend to learn too much and execute too little, so I have to focus on regularly putting out books, updating my checklist, making every book better and selling more of them to the audience that wants them. Which are you? Do you learn too much, execute too much without learning, or consider quitting? Tell me in the comments. If you would rather learn from other people’s failures, start with the top 3 mistakes people make self-publishing a book.
What does a broken mustard bottle have to do with self-publishing?
The other day I was making a sandwich and dropped the mustard bottle. It cracked at the bottom, leaving a big gap. I squeezed and nothing came out. It was a pressure problem: with a hole in the back, the bottle sucked air in instead of pushing mustard out. My fix was to put the cap on the front side and squeeze from the back. It was a terrible solution and made a mess, but it taught me that you need to understand how something works to win at it, and that when things break you need an alternative, even a worse one.
That is self-publishing. Much of it works fine and you don’t need to understand how. Then something breaks: Amazon changes something, tools get more expensive, shortcuts stop working. A lot of authors give up at the first adversity. Instead of getting angry at the bottle, ask whether there is another way.
Can a self-published book earn more than a traditionally published one?
Per copy, often yes. KDP’s 70% option pays 70% of the list price less delivery costs in the territories where it applies (KDP), and since 7-Jul-26 the 70% option covers ebook list prices from $2.99 to $12.99 on Amazon.com. The Authors Guild’s model contract has publishers paying 25% of net receipts on ebooks (that article is from 2011, so check any contract you are offered). Self-publishing also means you control the cover, the title, the price and the marketing, so you can keep improving a book that isn’t selling yet without a publisher’s permission.
The average traditionally published author may earn more than the average self-published author. But our goal isn’t to be average. It’s to be above average by optimizing your books. There is also an enormous audience of readers online, and some of them want your book. Publish in a market that doesn’t already have too many books, and learn the steps in my post on how I sold over 50K books.
What is the one mistake that guarantees failure?
Comparison. If you compare yourself with a huge success like The Martian, which began as a self-published ebook before Crown Publishing took it on, you get demotivated. Motivation keeps you in the game while you learn what works. Compare yourself only with your own last book: what can I do in the next one to make it better?
When Amazon or others break something, will you find a new solution or give up on self-publishing? Join communities, ask questions, and talk through strategies. That is how you make your book a success. What have you found? I reply to every comment.
If you want a coach to keep you learning and executing, see my self-publishing coaching.
Listen to this episode on Spotify
Frequently asked questions
How much do self-published authors earn?
The Authors Guild 2023 survey found full-time self-published authors had a median income of $12,800 from books in 2022, and $15,000 including other author-related work. That is a median, so half earned less.
Can a self-published book be picked up by a traditional publisher later?
Yes, it happens. Andy Weir sold The Martian as a 99-cent Kindle ebook in 2011, and Crown bought the print rights in 2013 (Wikipedia). See self-publishing an ebook first and approaching a publisher later.
Should I self-publish or keep trying a traditional publisher?
Self-publish if you want control and are willing to learn marketing, and query publishers if you want a publisher's reach and accept less control. You can do both with different books.
Want help with your book? Two ways to work with me
Group coaching
$47/month
You go through my 12 stages in order, and when a step stops you, you ask me in a private Slack group, by text, audio or video. I answer every question, usually the same day or the next. Cancel any time. 7-day money-back guarantee.
1-on-1 coaching
From $147/month
On your first call I show you the whole map for your book, where you are on it and your next step. Then one, two or three 55-minute Zoom calls a month, and private answers from me whenever you get stuck. 7-day money-back guarantee.
Rather have it done for you? See my publishing services.
Not sure yet? Book a free 25-minute call
Newest posts
- IngramSpark Standard vs Premium Color: Which Interior for Your Book?
- Which AI Should You Use to Write and Self-Publish a Book?
- What Can I Do Before My Manuscript Is Finished? Five Jobs to Start Now
- How Should I Title My Book's Chapters?
- Atticus or Reedsy Studio: Which Should You Use to Format Your Book?
Popular guides
- Lulu Self-Publishing Review 2026: Pros, Cons and Costs
- IngramSpark Review 2026: Free Setup, New Fees and Is It Worth It?
- Is Pegasus a Vanity Publisher? (2026 Update)
- Can You Sell Self Published Books On Etsy?
- How To Edit Your Books For Free With Grammarly
- Self Publishing Lulu VS Blurb?
- 5 Best Self Publishing Courses for Beginners (2026)
- How Long Should A Self-Published Book Be
- What Are The Minimum Amount Of Words For Paperback Books?
- Comparing Ingramspark, Lulu, and KDP Print
- How Many Books Do Self Published Authors Sell?
- Self-Publish For Under $199!


