Get the free publisher check: the questions to ask before you pay a publishing company.
Yes. Writer Beware, a watchdog sponsored by the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers Association, classifies Austin Macauley as a vanity publisher, not the “hybrid” publisher it calls itself. Authors pay to be published. Here is what the watchdog reports, what a vanity model means for you, and when I would pick self-publishing instead. If you want the wider comparison, see self-publishing versus vanity publishing.
What does Writer Beware say about Austin Macauley?
Writer Beware says it gets more reports and questions about Austin Macauley than about any other vanity publisher. In its post (first published 12-Jul-19, with an Austin Macauley update from 30-Apr-22) it says:
- Contracts it has seen charge authors between £1,275 and £7,700. Austin Macauley labels the fee “Advances,” though it is money the author pays the publisher.
- The contract it saw states no term for the grant of rights, and discontinuing publication is at the publisher’s discretion. Writer Beware calls that a life-of-copyright grant with weak rights-reversion terms.
- Fee-free contracts are sometimes offered, but Writer Beware says they are no bargain.
Writer Beware’s post covers seven publishers, and it says the Pegasus Elliot Mackenzie contract is word for word the same as Austin Macauley’s, so the same rights warning applies. See is Pegasus a vanity publisher.
Source: Writer Beware. Austin Macauley describes its own model as a “partnership publishing model” (Austin Macauley) and the homepage gives no details of author payments or contract terms. Contracts change, so get the current one in writing and have it checked by a lawyer or an author group before you sign.
What are the issues with vanity publishers?
When I started, authors told me what to watch for with any company like this. Who owns the rights? How much will it cost? Will they keep upselling services? How do I know the book will sell, and is marketing extra? How much do they take of the royalties, and can I ever break away? I also don’t like the word “vanity”. It sounds like you publish just to look good. But I understand why the word exists. Read my vanity publisher definition.
I chose to self-publish and learn the skills. I tried a whole pile of tools to get my books into the right formats, and today I recommend Atticus for EPUB and the other formats. Because I control the costs, I can pay more for a better cover or for formatting when I want. I control the distribution channels, I keep all the royalties and rights, and I choose the formats and the marketing. I need no permission to change the book. If you have the time to learn these skills, that is what I suggest. See where to find self-publishing editors.
How does Writer Beware say Austin Macauley finds authors, and can it market a book?
On how the company finds authors, Writer Beware says Austin Macauley recruits writers through “deceptively-headlined Google ads”. On what a vanity company can do for a book, it says it is unlikely to have the staff expertise, distribution channels or budget of a traditional publisher. That is the question I would put to the company in writing: what exactly will you do to sell my book, and what will it cost me?
Writer Beware’s April 2022 update also says Austin Macauley is one of the companies featured and analyzed in the UK Society of Authors’ report on what it calls the predatory “hybrid” or pay-to-play publishing sector. I have not read that report myself, so I only pass on what Writer Beware says about it. Whatever you read, ask a lawyer or an author group such as the Society of Authors to check any contract before you sign.
When could Austin Macauley still make sense?
Their pitch is that they do most of the work, walk you through a confusing process, and an author is rarely turned down. For some people, that is worth money. If you have money but not the time or motivation to learn self-publishing, and an agent and traditional publishers haven’t worked for you, it is a choice you can make. Just make it with the facts above in front of you, and compare it to paying for the services you need one by one.
Before you decide:
- Read recent reports from authors who used the company. A website’s own testimonials can’t tell you how old they are. Forums are better, and I wrote about what you can learn on self-publishing Reddit.
- Remember some people are negative about everything and some are paid to be positive. Read both sides.
- Ask for the full price list in writing, including marketing. My free publisher check puts the questions to ask about price, rights, royalties and your own accounts on one page. To sort the answers you already have, try my free publishing offer red flag checker.
Have you tried Austin Macauley? Tell me in the comments. It helps me know whether these posts are useful.
If you would rather keep control of your book and your costs, book a free 25-minute discovery call and we will look at what self-publishing would take for you.
Listen to this episode on Spotify
Frequently asked questions
What is a vanity publisher?
A company that makes its money from fees paid by the author, not from selling books to readers. Read my post on the vanity publisher definition.
What should I check in a publishing contract?
How much you pay, who owns the rights, how long the rights last, how you can get them back, what royalty you are paid, and what extra services you will be sold. Writer Beware says the Austin Macauley contract it saw set no term for the rights and left discontinuing publication to the publisher.
Is hybrid publishing the same as vanity publishing?
No. Real hybrid publishers share costs and risk and are selective. Writer Beware says the word hybrid is widely misused by vanity publishers and that any publisher calling itself hybrid needs a closer look, so judge the contract and not the label.

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird
Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.
Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.
Newest posts
- IngramSpark Standard vs Premium Color: Which Interior for Your Book?
- Which AI Should You Use to Write and Self-Publish a Book?
- What Can I Do Before My Manuscript Is Finished? Five Jobs to Start Now
- How Should I Title My Book's Chapters?
- Atticus or Reedsy Studio: Which Should You Use to Format Your Book?
Popular guides
- Lulu Self-Publishing Review 2026: Pros, Cons and Costs
- IngramSpark Review 2026: Free Setup, New Fees and Is It Worth It?
- Is Pegasus a Vanity Publisher? (2026 Update)
- Can You Sell Self Published Books On Etsy?
- How To Edit Your Books For Free With Grammarly
- Self Publishing Lulu VS Blurb?
- 5 Best Self Publishing Courses for Beginners (2026)
- How Long Should A Self-Published Book Be
- What Are The Minimum Amount Of Words For Paperback Books?
- Comparing Ingramspark, Lulu, and KDP Print
- How Many Books Do Self Published Authors Sell?
- Self-Publish For Under $199!

