Mindset

Is Pegasus a Vanity Publisher? (2026 Update)

Chris Baird pointing at the camera next to the words Pegasus Publishing?

Get the free publisher check: the questions to ask before you pay a publishing company.

Is Pegasus a vanity publisher? For authors who pay, it works like one. Pegasus Elliot Mackenzie offers shared-cost contracts, and Writer Beware lists it among seven prolific vanity publishers. It also reviews manuscripts and sets up distribution, which can make it look like a hybrid publisher. Below: how it works, what authors pay, how it compares with KDP, and the questions to ask before you sign anywhere.

This post is about the UK firm Pegasus Elliot Mackenzie Publishers, based in Cambridge. Pegasus Books is a different company.

What does Pegasus say about how it works?

Pegasus’s own site says it has worked with authors for more than two decades and is “accepting submissions”. Its publishing process page lists nine stages, from submitting your manuscript through an offer of publication, cover design, formatting, proofs and publication, to royalty updates. It says the review “may take up to six weeks”, that its publicists update “key book trade databases and distributors, including Nielsen and Gardners”, and that royalty statements come every six months.

What the page does not say is just as useful: it gives no fees, no royalty rates and no rights terms. Those are in the contract you are offered, so you only see them after the manuscript is accepted.

What is the difference between traditional, hybrid and vanity?

A traditional publisher pays you and carries the cost. A vanity press makes its money from author fees. The Alliance of Independent Authors (page dated 11-Jun-20) defines a vanity press as a service that uses misleading or, at worst, deceptive practices “with the intention not of bringing books to readers but of extracting as much money as possible from the authors”. That is ALLi’s general definition, not a finding about any one company. A hybrid or partnership publisher sits in between: it screens books, but the author pays part or all of the cost. With a shared-cost contract, the author pays towards the cost of publication and carries part of the risk. For the red flags, read what a vanity publisher is.

Is Pegasus a vanity publisher, yes or no?

It is both. No, in the sense that Pegasus does not accept every book. Pegasus says sending a manuscript does not guarantee an offer, and that it tells authors when it cannot publish them, so it acts as a gatekeeper. It also says it may offer traditional contracts as well as paid ones. A classic vanity press accepts almost anything and then upsells you on marketing, editing, proofreading, covers and keywords.

Yes, in the sense that the shared-cost contract has you paying, not the other way round. Pegasus’s own submissions page says it may offer a traditional contract or a shared-cost one, where the author contributes towards the cost. Writer Beware calls the shared-cost route “shared-cost inclusive” contracts, calls the author’s fee a “contribution”, and puts it at about 2,500 pounds on average from the authors it heard from, with the highest reported at 4,500 pounds (Writer Beware, 12-Jul-19, updated 18-Feb-26). Ask for the full price in writing before you agree to anything. If you are sorting out which publishers to avoid, my list of the worst self-publishing companies and the post on whether Page Publishing is a vanity publisher cover others.

How do the royalties and rights work?

Pegasus does not publish its royalty rates or rights terms. Writer Beware says that, with a few exceptions, its contracts are word for word identical to Austin Macauley’s. For Austin Macauley, Writer Beware says “there’s no stated term for the grant of rights” and that discontinuing publication is “entirely at the discretion of the publisher”. I have not seen a Pegasus contract, so treat that as a warning to read yours closely, not as what yours says. Ask what percentage you keep, on which sales (print, ebook, direct), and how you can get your rights back, and get the answer in the contract.

What does Writer Beware say about how the money works?

Writer Beware points out that vanity publishers make their money from author fees, so they have little reason to cut into that profit by paying for high-quality publishing and marketing. The fact that Pegasus says no to some manuscripts is a better sign than a publisher that takes anything. It does not change the main point: you pay, and you could keep far more on your own.

How does Pegasus compare with self-publishing on KDP?

TopicPegasus (shared-cost contract)KDP self-publishing
Cost to startNot published. Writer Beware reports about 2,500 pounds on averageKDP offers “free and simple tools”
RoyaltyNot published on its site. Statements every six monthsEbooks: 70% or 35%, 70% for $2.99 to $12.99 on Amazon.com. Paperback: 50% or 60% of list price minus printing
RightsPegasus says you keep copyright. Rights you grant are set out in the contractKDP says you “retain ownership of your content”
ControlPublisher sets up cover, layout and listingsKDP says it gives you control over content, design, price and advertising

The KDP figures change, so check the pages linked above before you publish. With a paid publisher you pay up front and share every sale. With KDP you pay only for the help you choose, such as an editor, a cover designer and a formatting tool, and you keep the rights. That is why I say you will make a lot more money if you do it yourself.

I did not start with a publisher. I wanted to put my ideas out into the world, so I went straight to Kindle Publishing, wrote a certain number of chapters a day until the book was done, then learned ads and marketing to get the sales up. I started with complete failure and sales grew over time. See Is Self Publishing To Kindle Difficult?

Along the way I heard many stories on podcasts and YouTube about companies that say “your book is wonderful, just send us money”. Then the sales are poor, so you need to send more money, or upgrade the cover package, and they also take a high share of the royalties. Some authors found the rights to their book sat with the publisher and they could not get them back without a big legal fight. I feel the pain of that wrong choice. Pegasus was not one of the companies in those stories.

If you have the money but not the time, a paid publisher can get a book printed. Compare the price with hiring an editor, cover designer and formatter yourself. Getting that first book out can be very motivating, and for later books you may decide to do it alone.

If you are weighing whether to pay a company like this, book a free 25-minute discovery call. Tell me where your book is now, and you leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

How do I check any publisher before signing?

Ask these questions:

  • Do you pay them, or do they pay you?
  • Who owns the ISBN?
  • Who holds the rights to your book, and for how long?
  • Can you leave, and get your rights back, if it does not work out?
  • Is the price published, or do you only hear it after they accept your book?
  • Is there a warning about them on Writer Beware or Reedsy?

You can take these questions with you as a free 2-page PDF, the publisher check. To go through an offer you already have, my free publishing offer red flag checker sorts your answers into serious, ask about this and fine, with the question to send for each.

Is Pegasus a vanity publisher? What have you found? Let me know below in the comments. I respond to all of them.

Frequently asked questions

Is Pegasus Elliot Mackenzie the same as Pegasus Books?

No. Pegasus Elliot Mackenzie Publishers is a UK firm based in Cambridge. Pegasus Books is a separate, unrelated publisher, so check which one you are reading about.

How much does it cost to publish with Pegasus?

Pegasus does not publish its prices. Writer Beware says authors it heard from paid about 2,500 pounds on average, and the highest was 4,500 pounds. Ask for the full price in writing before you agree to anything.

Can I get my rights back from a vanity publisher?

Only if the contract says how. Writer Beware says Pegasus contracts are, with a few exceptions, word for word the same as Austin Macauley's, and that Austin Macauley's has no stated term for the grant of rights. Ask about this before you sign.

What is the cheaper way to publish a book?

Self-publish on KDP and IngramSpark, which give you free tools, and pay only for an editor, cover designer and formatting tool as you need them. I can help you pick the right route on a free discovery call.

Chris Baird

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.

Newest posts

Tags

Start with the free checklist

The 12 steps I follow for every book I publish. It is free, and you get it straight away.

You get the free checklist and Chris's emails. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy

Before you pay a publishing company: the questions to ask

A free 2-page PDF of the questions to ask about price, rights, royalties and your own accounts, so you know the answers before you sign.

Get the free questions

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.