Book Formatting

Releasing a Good vs Perfect Book: When Is It Ready?

Chris Baird smiling and raising a hand beside the words Good vs. perfect?

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through one, Urgesta AS may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Read the affiliate disclosure.

Book a free 25-minute call. Tell me where your book is now.

A good book is one that earns between three and five stars from real readers, and you should publish it before it feels perfect. Perfect is the enemy of good: the longer you edit, the longer you wait for readers to tell you what to fix. Here is what I learned from over-editing my first books, how to fix a book after it is live and why the best thing you can do is keep publishing.

Why do authors get stuck trying to make the book perfect?

You have finished the first book. You format it, get a cover, maybe do some editing, and it still is not quite right. So you edit again. If the book never reaches the market, nobody can tell you it was bad, and you avoid embarrassment. But you also never find out what readers want, and you never write the next book. It is a common loop, and a lot of finished books never get published because of it.

How much editing did my first books need?

My first three books went through at least four to five rounds of editing with two separate editors, plus tools such as ProWritingAid, Grammarly, Word and LibreOffice. I listened to the books and read them several times. Then I released them and they sold, but the cost of all those rounds was high.

So I tested the idea. I had a series of books written by other people on keywords I knew were popular, and I gave them far less editing. I saw little difference in the response. Grammar mistakes can put off some readers, who may think the author is not a native speaker, but readers are forgiving when the story is compelling or the nonfiction solves their problem. They do not ask how many rounds of editing the book has had.

What I use now is Grammarly for the basics and Voice Dream Reader to listen to the book. Listening is a great way to find mistakes, and if you have a Kindle book you can have it read to you. Some premium voices cost extra, so check the price in the app. I’m not a partner with them. For help with the editing decision, see how to hire a professional book editor and how to build a self-publishing team.

So what is a good book?

A book that is on Amazon and whose organic reviews come in between three and five stars. Notice I did not say five. Five stars across the board would be a perfect book, and nobody gets that. If the book is getting one to two stars, something is broken: it makes a promise and fails to deliver, or the formatting is wrong. Leave out reviews that complain about Amazon’s delivery or a download problem, because you can’t fix those.

If you are not getting three stars, your quality is too low, so raise it. Reviews are social proof, and they matter for sales (see how to get Amazon book reviews). This three-to-five-star test is my own rule of thumb.

Can I fix my book after it is published?

Yes, and many authors do not know that. If readers point out formatting or grammar errors, you correct the file and upload it again for both the paperback and the Kindle book. This is one reason I argue for doing the work yourself. I formatted all my books myself (with Jutoh back then; today I recommend Atticus), so a fix is quick. A traditionally published author needs the publisher’s permission, and the publisher has no interest unless the book sells thousands.

Two limits. For ebooks, KDP delivers updated content to earlier buyers automatically, but its customer update requests are reserved for critical quality issues that significantly affect readability, and readers who turned off automatic updates must update manually (KDP help). For paperbacks, fixing typos does not usually need a new ISBN, but a new edition with substantial changes may. Check with the agency that issued your ISBN.

Also ask yourself: if the book has never been on the market, how do you know it isn’t perfect or is? Readers can’t tell you what is wrong with it. They do tell you what is right, and if they keep making the same complaint, you learn from it.

What is the top thing you can do to sell more books?

Put more books on the market. People push back and say their books must be perfect. If you publish garbage you will get one and two stars. But if you get three, four or five stars and improve with each book, you will make sales, and you can reinvest in better covers, keyword research and tools. Ads and content marketing help too, once you have a few books out.

Someone gave the acronym ABS, Always Be Shipping (I forget who, so tell me in the comments). When you keep shipping, a small part of your products usually accounts for most of your sales, and if you have no products out, there is nothing to sell. It works for my YouTube videos too: my audience told me to improve the camera, the microphone and the background, and I could not have heard that by waiting for a perfect video.

Perfect is not going to work. If you want to learn to fish, don’t watch thousands of videos and spend all your time on bait, reel and hook. Throw the line into the water. People are not paying that much attention to you. Your biggest problem as a new author is not that readers laugh at you, but that nobody discovers you. Get something out, learn from readers and write the next one. Attention comes from more content and more books.

There are fake gurus and vanity publishers who are glad to make your book perfect for as long as you keep paying them. My goal is to give you the tools and mindset to get a good book on the market and improve it over time. If you keep overthinking it, see why you should not overthink self-publishing.

When did you last put a book on the market? Are you waiting for yours to be perfect? Tell me in the comments. If you have a book that is stuck, book a free 25-minute discovery call and we will decide together whether it is good enough to ship.

Frequently asked questions

How many rounds of editing does a book need?

Fewer than you think. I used four to five rounds on my first three books and later saw little difference in response with less editing. Do the basics well, then let readers show you what to fix.

Can I update my book after it is published on KDP?

Yes. You can upload a corrected file. KDP says updated ebook content is delivered automatically to earlier buyers, but customer updates are reserved for critical quality issues that significantly affect readability (KDP).

Do I need a new ISBN if I fix mistakes in my paperback?

Minor corrections such as typos generally do not need a new ISBN, but a substantial change to the content, title or format usually does. Check your ISBN agency's rules for your case.

Chris Baird

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.

Newest posts

Tags

Start with the free checklist

The 12 steps I follow for every book I publish. It is free, and you get it straight away.

You get the free checklist and Chris's emails. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.