Book Creation

Self-Publishing: The Best Option for You?

Chris Baird with a hand on the chin, with the words Best Option?

Book a free 25-minute call. Tell me where your book is now.

Self-publishing is better than a hybrid publisher for most authors, because you keep control of your book, your files and your sales numbers. Greta, a romance author, paid a hybrid company, got a sales report with no sales, and was quoted about a hundred dollars for each change. Here is her story, what I told her, and who should still consider a hybrid. For another company people ask about, see what I think about self-publishing with Dale.

What went wrong with the hybrid publisher?

Greta is a romance author in Germany with a couple of books on Amazon. She was dreading finding another hybrid company for her next one. She had gone with the first because formatting, editing, cover design, accounts, distribution across channels, and later an audiobook all seemed confusing.

Her bad experiences were many. The book was not under her own account, so the company had to tell her about sales. Once they had her money, they had little motivation to answer questions. She had to chase them, and the sales report showed no sales. They then offered to market the book for a thousand dollars. She found spelling and formatting mistakes and unequal margins. When she asked to add paragraphs, they quoted around a hundred dollars a change, and work had been outsourced elsewhere, where the staff didn’t fully understand her requests. She told me she owns the copyright, but who cares about the copyright if you don’t control the book and its formatting?

Can I trust a hybrid publisher’s reviews?

Greta found the same pattern in other hybrid publishers. The sales pages had testimonials, but she could not find the customers anywhere. Facebook groups and other sites had complaints, and she heard that complaint sites got taken down or threatened. There weren’t communities of happy customers, the way there are for products people love. That made her doubt the whole hybrid model.

Writer Beware, which tracks the industry, tracks vanity and pay-to-play publishers. Its 16-Oct-26 post on Starfish Bay Publishing, a publisher that asked authors for a “temporary loan”, puts it plainly: “Pay to play is pay to play.” Read self-publishing companies to avoid before you pay anyone.

Why do I recommend self-publishing instead?

You control everything. She posted her question on Quora, then booked a free 25-minute discovery call. We looked at her romance novels and saw cover mistakes and descriptions that weren’t optimized. I told her what I tell everyone:

  1. You outsource what you can’t do, such as cover design and editing, but you choose who and what price. If you’re unhappy, hire someone else. On Upwork and Fiverr you can see ratings. On 99designs, you can try different covers, with the lowest contest package at $299 on its page.
  2. You only pay for what you need. I recommend Atticus for formatting. If you want a new paragraph, change a style or fix a margin, you do it and export the EPUB or PDF.
  3. You publish on as many sites as you like and see your sales on the dashboard, instead of an intermediary who decides what to tell you.

Our policy is not to spend lots of resources going back to old books. We optimize them if we have the files, but we use time on future books. I also told another person who asked about a $900 social media marketing package: no. Content marketing and ads are the way, and neither needs $900 up front.

What if I don’t know which cover or editor is right?

Just choose one and do it. Ready, fire, aim. You will make mistakes. When you’re running a marathon, you don’t spend your time on which shoes to wear. You start running and change shoes when your feet hurt. Motion is the key. I know people who talk about publishing for years because they want it perfect. Get something out there, then see what worked. Read 3 common self-publishing questions.

What should a hybrid contract say before I sign?

If you still want a hybrid publisher, read the contract first. The Authors Guild’s page on hybrid contracts, dated 30-Jul-26, says you should understand exactly how royalties are calculated, and that some presses deduct printing and distribution costs before the split, which can change what you receive a lot. It says an author should never have to buy copies of their own work to get a publisher to sign, and that you should ask to remove option clauses. It also says you should be able to end the agreement at any time, but ending it does not mean you get back money already paid. I am not a lawyer, so have one read it.

Is self-publishing the best option for you?

For 99% of you, I think yes. Almost everyone I know who has self-published says it was a good idea, even though they had to learn formatting, covers, editors, audiobooks and how to keep tweaking their pages. Hardly anyone tells me self-publishing was the worst mistake of their life and they should have gone with a hybrid. Some never finish. If you have the money and no time, a hybrid may get a book on the market, but I do not recommend it for most authors.

Greta ended up feeling empowered. For the first time she had control over her books. She also asked which sites to put the book on, because the hybrid company had always chosen. I pointed her to the best self-publishing platform for authors.

If you are weighing hybrid publishing against doing it yourself, book a free 25-minute discovery call before you pay anyone.

Frequently asked questions

Is self-publishing better than a hybrid publisher?

For most authors, yes. You keep control of your book, your files and your sales numbers, and you choose who you hire and at what price.

What goes wrong with hybrid publishers?

Greta's book was not under her own account, so the company had to tell her about sales, and the report showed none. She found formatting mistakes and was quoted about a hundred dollars for each change.

How do I check whether a publisher is trustworthy?

Look for real customers behind the testimonials and for complaints on Facebook groups and other sites. Writer Beware tracks vanity and pay-to-play publishers.

Do I need to be perfect before choosing a cover or editor?

No. Just choose one and do it, then see what worked. Motion is the key, and you can change later.

What should I check in a hybrid publisher's contract?

The Authors Guild says to understand exactly how royalties are calculated, check what costs are deducted before the split, never agree to buy copies of your own book to get signed, and ask to remove option clauses. Have a lawyer read it.

Chris Baird

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.

Newest posts

Tags

Start with the free checklist

The 12 steps I follow for every book I publish. It is free, and you get it straight away.

You get the free checklist and Chris's emails. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.