Book Formatting

Is Penguin Publishing Worth It?

Chris Baird pointing, with the words Penguin Publishing?

Book a free 25-minute call. Tell me where your book is now.

Penguin Random House does not charge authors to publish a book. It is a traditional publisher: it pays you for the right to publish your book. So is Penguin Publishing worth it? Its own guide says “getting a book deal should never be a ‘pay to play’ scenario” (Penguin Random House). Whether it is worth it depends on whether you can get in, and on how much you want to keep control of your book. After 230 books, my view is that most authors should learn the steps themselves and keep their rights. Below I cover what Penguin charges, how a traditional deal works, and how it compares with the other two routes.

Does Penguin Random House charge authors to publish?

No. A traditional publisher pays you, not the other way round. PRH warns readers to “be wary of agent or publisher scams out there that require money up-front to be traditionally published” (PRH, How can I get published?, 21-Mar-22). So if someone asks you for thousands of dollars to publish with “Penguin”, you are not dealing with Penguin Random House.

How do you get published by Penguin Random House?

Usually through a literary agent. PRH says “historically, most major publishers, including Penguin Random House, have not accepted unagented submissions,” and that an agent is still required and advisable in most cases (PRH, How can I get published?, 21-Mar-22). It also says it is working to create and expand open submission opportunities, for example the Berkley Open Submission Program. Check the imprint’s own page for the current rules, because those windows open and close.

So you pitch agents, you may be turned down many times, and perhaps you are eventually taken on and your agent sells the book. PRH says agents only get paid when they sell your work. The usual commission is 15% (Writer Beware), taken from what you earn, not charged to you up front.

What does a traditional publisher pay you?

You are paid through a contract, and the terms differ from book to book. As a guide, the Authors Guild cited 15% of list price for a hardcover, and said standard contracts gave authors 25% of the publisher’s net receipts on ebooks, a rate it argued was too low (Authors Guild, 09-Jul-15). That page is from 2015, so treat the figures as a starting point and read your own contract, ideally with your agent or a lawyer.

The trade-off is control. The publisher holds the right to publish for the contract term and usually sets the price, the cover and the timing.

Does Penguin sell paid publishing packages or have a self-publishing arm?

Not that Penguin Random House’s own imprint directory shows today. It lists its traditional publishing imprints and links to guidance called “Avoid Publishing Scams” (PRH imprints). Where the old advice about Penguin gets muddled is Author Solutions.

In 2012 Penguin’s then-parent company Pearson bought Author Solutions, a large paid self-publishing company. Penguin Random House sold it to an affiliate of the Najafi Companies, a private investment firm, in a deal that closed on 31-Dec-15 and was reported in January 2016. Writer Beware’s post adds, quoting David Gaughran, that Author Solutions still ran four imprints for PRH after the sale: the three Partridge imprints and MeGustaEscribir (Writer Beware, 05-Jan-16). I have not checked whether those four imprints still operate today, so treat them as a reason to look closely at the contract rather than a current list.

The safe rule is simple. A company that sells you a package is not Penguin, whatever its name sounds like. See Is Pegasus a vanity publisher? for how I check one, and red flags with hybrid publishing companies before you sign anything.

What did I decide when I started?

When I got started, I had heard about publishing houses that would do it all for you. You send the manuscript, and they edit, format, design the cover and put the whole thing together, with marketing packages that cost thousands of dollars. The idea is that you focus on writing.

The risk is that in many of these cases the company owns the rights, takes a big share of each sale, and has no interest in fixing a mistake once it has been paid. Many of the podcasts and books I was reading at the time said to stay away from them, because you need to own the rights to your books.

So I did it myself. I broke the steps down into something simple. At first I felt the overload of too many steps in my head, and I almost gave up, until I found that it does not have to be so hard. That is why I created this blog and my YouTube channel. I have published 230 books since.

Will having Penguin on the book sell more copies?

Not by itself. The average reader does not look at who published the book. They look at the reviews, the cover and the description to decide whether it is the right book for them. You may care about the publisher’s name, but your readers mostly won’t.

How do the three routes compare?

TopicTraditional (such as Penguin Random House)Paid publishing companySelf-publishing
Cost to youNothing up front; a reputable agent usually takes 15% of what you earnYou pay up front, often thousands of dollarsYou pay for the help you choose, such as editing, a cover and ads
Who owns the rightsThe publisher holds the right to publish for the contract termCheck the contractYou keep them
Who sets the priceThe publisherOften the companyYou
What you earnA royalty set in the contractA share of sales, set in the contractOn Amazon.com, KDP pays 70% on ebooks priced $2.99 to $12.99 and 35% otherwise (KDP royalties, KDP price bands)

Which route is worth it for you? If you have the time, learn the skills yourself and spend as little as you can. For formatting I recommend Atticus. Once you have a few books out, you can outsource parts of the work, as I do with virtual assistants who put the books together once they are written. I break down the costs in how much it costs to write and publish a book. To see what self-publishing could earn you next to a traditional deal, try the free self-publishing vs traditional calculator.

If you have the money but not the time or the computer skills, a paid book-production company can make sense, if you check it carefully first. Ask who owns the rights, what it takes from each sale, and whether you can leave.

If you are not sure which route fits your book, book a free 25-minute discovery call and we can talk it through. You may be surprised at what you can do yourself if you give it a go.

Wondering if doing it yourself is the better choice? See is self publishing a book a good idea.

Have you tried publishing with a traditional house or a paid company? Tell me in the comments how it went. I would really like to hear it.

Frequently asked questions

Does Penguin Random House charge authors to publish?

No. Its own guide says getting a book deal should never be a pay-to-play scenario, and it warns about agents and publishers that require money up front. A traditional publisher pays you for the right to publish your book.

How do you get published by Penguin Random House?

Usually through a literary agent. PRH says most major publishers, including itself, have historically not accepted unagented submissions and that an agent is still required and advisable in most cases, though it is working to expand open submissions.

Does Penguin have a self-publishing service or paid packages?

Not that its imprint directory shows. Penguin Random House sold Author Solutions, the paid self-publishing company, at the end of 2015. A company that sells you a package is not Penguin, whatever its name sounds like.

How much do traditional publishers pay in royalties?

It depends on the contract. In 2015 the Authors Guild cited 15% of list price for a hardcover and the standard ebook royalty as 25% of the publisher's net receipts, and it argued the ebook share should be higher. Read your own contract before you sign.

Is it better to self-publish or use a publishing company?

If you have the time, learn the skills yourself and keep your rights. If you have the money but not the time, a paid book-production company can make sense if you check who owns the rights, what it takes from each sale and whether you can leave.

Chris Baird

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.

Newest posts

Tags

Start with the free checklist

The 12 steps I follow for every book I publish. It is free, and you get it straight away.

You get the free checklist and Chris's emails. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.