Book Formatting

Self-Publishing Mistakes to Avoid

Chris Baird pointing at the viewer, with the words Mistakes?

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through one, Urgesta AS may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Read the affiliate disclosure.

Book a free 25-minute call. Tell me where your book is now.

The biggest self-publishing mistakes are waiting for a perfect book, never testing your title and cover on real readers, and skipping keywords. Gary, a fantasy author, made all three. He wrote six books and published none. Here is his story, and how he fixed it.

What is the biggest self-publishing mistake?

Gary was starting his seventh book. He had not published his first. He wanted to be a best-selling author, and his fantasy books were as good as Lord of the Rings style epics, with great storylines. I had skimmed them and they looked fine. But he was still on his 10th or 15th round of editing, sending the book to different editors who found more issues. He believed a bestseller must be perfect. He also sent his cover back to the designer several times, then switched to another designer.

He downloaded my free 12-step self-publishing checklist, saw that editing and covers are only steps in a sequence, and we started emailing. He was a perfectionist, and he was never going to put the books on the market. Read releasing a good vs perfect book and perfectionism vs self-doubt.

How do I choose a title and cover?

Match the genre. A common mistake is a cover that doesn’t match the genre, such as a romance-style cover on a Lord of the Rings style fantasy. A common second mistake is a poor title that doesn’t do what the book needs. Gary’s cover was fine, from a professional designer, and his title fit the genre and used keywords in the subtitle. It needed only a small change.

But you never know if a cover and title work until readers see them. By keeping the books off the market, Gary got no feedback. He knew what he liked, which may not be what his audience likes.

How do I test my cover and title?

Run Amazon ads. They show how many impressions you got, how many clicks and how many sales, so you can see whether people are interested in your cover and title. Amazon’s Sponsored Products are pay-per-click, so you pay only when someone clicks. My own ads have passed 200 million views. Read 3 ways to make sure your book bombs for what not to do.

Giving up on ads too early is a mistake my clients make. We go back and forth on it in coaching. You can add a short line to the ad to help the audience understand, such as “an epic adventure.” Gary could not do any of this, because you can’t run ads against a book that isn’t for sale.

Which keywords should I use?

Words your readers search for, in the title and subtitle. I use KDSpy to find them. Read how to use keywords on Amazon KDP.

Do you assume there is a market for your book?

This is another common mistake. Readers are not looking for any book on any subject. For non-fiction, check that people really have the problem you solve. For fiction, check that your type of fiction is still selling. You do not have to write books you have no interest in, but you need a balance between what people are buying now and what you want to write. Skip this step and you could write a whole series that nobody wants. For what makes a topic sell, see the 3 elements of a marketable non-fiction book.

Does spending more on editing and covers pay off?

Not always. In the Written Word Media 2025 indie author survey (published 2-Dec-25), most authors earning over $10,000 a month spent between $250 and $1,999 on editing, and the survey calls $250 to $999 a sweet spot. It found no clear link between spending $2,000 or more on a cover and higher income. The figures are self-reported and show a pattern, not a cause. Orna Ross of the Alliance of Independent Authors says in a talk with Joanna Penn that it is always a mistake to forego the editing (published 11-Dec-20). So pay for a clean edit and a cover that looks like your category’s best sellers, then publish.

Why is doing it all alone a mistake?

Self-publishing has many steps and it is easy to get them wrong. Our family once joined a scouting group in Norway and failed to light a fire with newspaper and big logs. Another dad split the logs, arranged the thinner pieces around the paper, and we had a fire in minutes. It looked simple when he did it. The dad who showed me saved me hours, which is why I have a business coach and why I coach other authors. In the same talk, Orna Ross says to talk to somebody who can actually help you.

What happened to Gary?

His motivation fell. He was excited to write, but demotivated by the idea of getting the books to sell. He was tempted to start the seventh book because he knew where the story went, and put the first out later. His fix was to stop writing more books. We only need books that earn three to five stars, so that readers can start telling us what they like. Ignoring the audience is an option, but it costs you.

He put his first book on the market and ran Amazon ads. He saw a few things to change in the title and cover, tweaked them, and sales began to come. In his case perfectionism was the mistake. Others rush, and the next book should be better. But you can’t improve if your books aren’t on the market.

How much does it cost to test with ads?

You set the budget. Amazon says Sponsored Products campaigns “have no monthly or upfront fees,” you pay only when a shopper clicks, and you set a daily budget that you can change after launch. Your total spend never goes over the amount you set for the campaign. KDP authors can use the ads (Amazon Ads: Sponsored Products). I won’t give you a number to spend, because it depends on your book and your budget. Start small, and let the clicks and sales tell you whether to change the title or cover.

Is a book of yours stuck in endless editing? Book a free 25-minute discovery call and we will decide together whether it is ready to publish.

Frequently asked questions

What are the biggest self-publishing mistakes?

Waiting for a perfect book, never testing your title and cover on real readers, and skipping keywords.

How do I test my cover and title?

Run Amazon ads. They show impressions, clicks and sales, so you can see whether people are interested in your cover and title. Sponsored Products ads are pay-per-click, so you pay only when someone clicks.

Which keywords should I use?

Words your readers search for, in the title and subtitle. The author uses KDSpy to find them.

Is it a mistake to keep editing a book?

It can be. Gary was on his 10th or 15th round of editing and never published. Once he put his first book on the market and ran ads, he tweaked the title and cover and sales began to come.

Do Amazon ads have a monthly fee?

No. Amazon says Sponsored Products have no monthly or upfront fees. You pay when someone clicks, and you set a daily budget.

Chris Baird

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.

Newest posts

Tags

Start with the free checklist

The 12 steps I follow for every book I publish. It is free, and you get it straight away.

You get the free checklist and Chris's emails. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.