Book Formatting

Self-Publishing vs Traditional Publishing: Who Wins?

Chris Baird with a hand on his chin beside the words Self-pub vs traditional?

Book a free 25-minute call. Tell me where your book is now.

For most new authors, start with self-publishing. Traditional publishers want books that will sell, so a self-published book with readers behind it is your best pitch later. Self-publishing also pays more per sale and lets you control rights and distribution. Here is how the two compare, what I did, and a way to try both.

What is the difference between self-publishing and traditional publishing?

Traditional publishing is a gatekeeper. You send a manuscript and it is accepted or rejected. It gives you status, since a major publisher chose you. The downsides are real: you need connections or an agent, a book at the highest quality, a sense of which books are selling, and usually a following, because the publisher wants a return on its investment. In the end, they probably won’t market your book much, so you will do that yourself. These are the same steps you would do self-publishing.

Self-publishing has no gatekeeper. Anybody can put a book out, which is the reason it has less status. But you control the whole process and the rights.

Which pays more?

FormatSelf-published on KDPTraditional (Authors Guild model contract)
Ebook70% of list price on Amazon.com for books priced $2.99 to $12.9925% of the publisher’s net receipts
Paperback60% of list price minus printing cost at $9.99 or more, 50% below that7.5% of retail
HardcoverSet by you10% of retail on the first 5,000 copies, 12.5% on the next 5,000, then 15%

A model contract is not what every publisher pays, and net receipts pay considerably less per copy than list-price royalties at the same percentage. Pay is also not the same as income: the Authors Guild’s 2023 survey of 5,699 published authors found a median book income of $2,000 for 2022 across all authors and $12,800 for full-time self-published authors.

Why did I start with self-publishing?

I wasn’t tempted by the traditional route. I knew it was incredibly difficult and I wanted to keep things simple. I did not want to figure out how to contact publishers and send in manuscripts. I wanted to see if I could get a book on Amazon and make money from it. It was confusing at first, and I broke basic rules and got very few sales. By following the right steps, I saw the sales come. If you are just starting, you don’t have an audience, and your chances with a publisher are slim.

How do I self-publish step by step?

  1. Start with the Kindle book. Get the description, keywords, title and cover right, collect reviews and build an audience. Amazon is the best place to start. See how to start self-publishing with Amazon Kindle.
  2. Add the paperback through KDP. I recommend Atticus for formatting.
  3. Add the audiobook through ACX.
  4. Don’t stop with Amazon. Hardcovers through Lulu or IngramSpark, which gives wider distribution, put your books on more shelves in libraries and stores in many countries. See my IngramSpark review.

I have books out under my own name and under pen names. It is usually best to keep a pen name to one genre.

What do traditional publishers actually do for authors today?

In the old days you sent a manuscript, and if accepted, editors, the cover, the title and publicity were handled for you. Times have changed. Publishers earn less now that books are easy to publish, so they spend marketing money mostly on books that are already selling. Book tours and signings usually come once you’re famous. If you self-publish and become popular, publishers become interested and may drive the whole package.

Authors I listened to on podcasts described the other side: the publisher did no marketing, the book had no reviews or purchases, royalties came late or not at all, and getting the rights back after signing a contract and taking an advance took years. Once they had the rights, they could change the cover, title and content. They said they wouldn’t go the traditional route again. A book displayed in a store goes on a shelf with thousands of others. These are stories I heard, not research.

Some authors tell me they only felt like an author after getting past the gatekeepers. I think that is nonsense. My family member said I would be an author once I sold a thousand copies. After 230 books I have sold over 50,000, and my books are on library shelves around the world. I am biased toward self-publishing, but traditional may be right for you. When did you last check who published the book you were reading? I never do. Reviews and rankings decide what I read.

Should I query agents first or self-publish now?

If you want a traditional deal, query agents first. If you want to publish soon and keep control, self-publish now. The order matters. Jane Friedman, who has advised authors on this for years, writes that agents and publishers “have little or no interest in acquiring self-published work” unless the book has had significant media attention or hit bestseller lists (updated 28-Apr-25).

So the choice is about timing. Querying costs you nothing but waiting, and a rejection leaves a clean book you can still self-publish. Self-publishing first makes sense when you do not care about a traditional deal, or when you are ready to build readers and sales yourself. Friedman says there is no fixed number a book must reach, since it varies by genre, author and price. Her example of a strong pitch is a book that has sold 50,000 copies. If you query, check any agent against the literary agent scam reports at Writer Beware first.

A real publisher contacted me about my self-published book. What do I check?

Check who is writing to you, what the contract says about your rights, and whether you are being asked to pay. Do not sign anything until someone who knows publishing contracts has read it.

  • Who they are. A traditional publisher pays you. Writer Beware says of one publisher whose authors had to hand over a large sum before publication that “pay to play is pay to play”, however it is described. Search the publisher’s name on Writer Beware before you reply.
  • Which rights you give away. Writer Beware criticises one set of contracts for claiming “a large menu of rights” and having no provision for getting rights back. That example is about magazines, but the same questions apply to a book contract: which rights are included, and how do you get them back if the book is not published or stops selling?
  • A second pair of eyes. The Authors Guild offers a line-by-line contract review to its members, with suggested changes and negotiation tips. An agent or a lawyer who knows publishing contracts can do the same.

I have not signed a traditional contract, so I can’t tell you what it feels like. If you get an offer, the free call below is a good place to talk it through before you reply.

Can I try both?

Yes. Set a time limit of three to six months and see whether a publisher will accept your book. If you want an agent, you will need one. If a company asks you to pay, it is not a traditional publisher but a vanity or hybrid one: a traditional publisher pays you, or simply agrees to publish. Submit to traditional publishers first and give them a chance to reject you. If they do, self-publish it. In my experience publishers and agents prefer books that have not been self-published yet, so each new book should go to them before you publish it yourself. A book you have already self-published is a hard sell. This is my own approach, not a rule from any publisher.

Meanwhile you learn what readers want, where to find an audience and how to get them to buy, with social media and content marketing. When your audience builds, you can show a publisher that people want your books, and then they may say yes. Authors who keep sending to publishers and being rejected tend to lose motivation, and nobody sees the book. Most people who see the money from self-publishing don’t want to step down for a publisher. For some, the status or their job makes it worth it. Read 11 top reasons to self-publish on Kindle and the vanity publisher definition.

To put your own numbers through both routes, use my free self-publishing vs traditional earnings calculator. You type in the price and royalty from the offer you have.

Have you tried traditional publishing, or both? Tell me in the comments. If you would like help with your first book, book a free 25-minute discovery call.

Frequently asked questions

Should I self-publish or go traditional?

For most new authors, start with self-publishing. Traditional publishers want books that will sell, so a self-published book with readers behind it is your best pitch later.

Which pays more, self-publishing or traditional?

Self-publishing pays more per sale. KDP pays 70% of list price on ebooks priced $2.99 to $12.99 on Amazon.com, against 25% of the publisher's net receipts in the Authors Guild model contract.

Should I query agents first or self-publish now?

If you want a traditional deal, query agents first. If you want to publish soon and keep control, self-publish now.

Can I try both routes?

Yes. Set a time limit of three to six months to see whether a publisher will accept your book, and meanwhile build an audience you can show them.

What should I check if a publisher contacts me about my self-published book?

Who is writing to you, what the contract says about your rights, and whether you are being asked to pay. Do not sign anything until someone who knows publishing contracts has read it.

Chris Baird

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.

Newest posts

Tags

Start with the free checklist

The 12 steps I follow for every book I publish. It is free, and you get it straight away.

You get the free checklist and Chris's emails. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird

Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.

Book your free call

Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.