Get the free checklist: the 12 steps I follow for every book I publish.
Readers hate three things: poor formatting, emails about something they did not sign up for, and books that do not deliver what they promise. The first one surprises people, because the free route on formatting is what brings one-star reviews. I’ll show how it played out for Jill, a writer who had all three problems, and how she fixed them.
What did the one-star reviews on Jill’s books come from?
Jill lives in New Mexico and writes two kinds of books: cozy mysteries (the kind with cupcakes on the cover) and vertical gardening books. The detective in her mysteries is a gardener, so she thought the two would blend. She gave away a vertical gardening reference guide to get gardening readers on her email list, and a short story to get mystery readers. Then she emailed the list about her latest books.
It was not working. She got one-star reviews, people unsubscribed, and some marked her emails as spam. Her friends did better with the same approach. She began to doubt that she was good enough as a writer. It turned out her readers did not hate her. She had three fixable problems.
1. Why does free formatting bring bad reviews?
Jill ran her Word file through Calibre, and also through Draft2Digital’s converter, which gives an EPUB she could upload. The result still had broken bullet points and extra text. Her ebook looked wrong, and readers said so in reviews.
KDP says Word files with complex formatting may not convert well, and suggests checking every file in Kindle Previewer. Sending the book to someone else to format is not a fix either, because you can’t change it yourself. The best way is to format it yourself with a tool made for books. Jill bought the formatting tool I recommended back then. Today I recommend Atticus. I explain why in why you should format your book yourself and the secret of formatting your books right. I used a desktop formatting program for years, and it takes a few passes to get a book exactly right.
Paying for a tool is an investment in your business. You plant a seed in the ground, and sometimes you have to spend something first.
2. Why do readers mark your emails as spam?
Because the emails are not about what they signed up for. Readers who joined for a cozy mystery short story did not want gardening emails. Mentioning gardening inside the mysteries was not close enough. These are two audiences with two different problems, and trying to serve both waters down your authority in each.
My advice was two pen names and two email lists, so everyone knows what is in the email before they open it. I wrote about pen names for authors and about creating an email list for self-publishers. Jill kept the mysteries and moved the gardening to another pen name. Spam complaints also affect whether your emails arrive: Google asks senders to keep the spam rate below 0.10% and never reach 0.30%, and under the US CAN-SPAM Act you must honor an unsubscribe request within 10 business days and your subject line must match the content.
Changing the subject line to say “gardening” or “cozy mysteries”, as Jill tried, did not help. The topic of the email has to match the list.
3. What happens when a book does not deliver what it promised?
Jill’s gardening books said up front what they would cover, and the content did not give it. Some of the complaints in her reviews were about that, not only the formatting. She was a stronger expert in mysteries than in gardening, and readers noticed.
Listen to your readers’ comments. Fix the book, and put the same promise in the description and the book. Give them what they came for.
Can KDP remove a book that disappoints readers?
KDP’s content guidelines say books for sale on Amazon should provide a positive customer experience, and that they cover the title, cover art and product description, which must not be meant to mislead customers. KDP says it can reject or remove content that doesn’t follow them, and can remove a book from sale if it creates a poor customer experience. If it removes a title it notifies you, and you can appeal. The page doesn’t mention reviews or give any number, so don’t read it as a rule about star ratings. It does show that Amazon expects the cover, title and description to match the book, just as your readers do.
What changed for Jill?
She worked through my free 12-step checklist, and we swapped emails to find the problems. Then she formatted the book herself with a proper tool, focused on cozy mysteries, and moved gardening to a separate pen name. The one-star reviews about formatting stopped. The spam complaints stopped. People still unsubscribe, and they always will, but now the list is all about cozy mysteries and the readers who stay are excited about her new books.
Choosing one niche takes time. Three to five years of steady work to get going, in my experience, and ten to build something big, with the formatting right, the comments used to improve the next book, and the strategies applied. Don’t spread across four niches in the hope that one pays.
Have you had hate from your readers? Write yes or no in the comments, and tell me which of the three it was.
Listen to this episode on Spotify
Frequently asked questions
What do readers hate most in self-published books?
Poor formatting, emails about something they did not sign up for, and books that do not deliver what the cover and description promise.
Why does free formatting bring bad reviews?
Free converters can leave broken bullet points and extra text in an ebook, and readers say so in reviews. KDP says Word files with complex formatting may not convert well, and suggests checking every file in Kindle Previewer.
Why do readers mark my emails as spam?
Because the emails are not about what they signed up for. Two audiences with two different problems need two email lists, so everyone knows what is in the email before they open it.
What spam rate is too high?
Google asks senders to keep the spam rate below 0.10% and never reach 0.30%.
Can KDP remove a book that disappoints readers?
KDP says it can reject or remove content that does not follow its guidelines, and can remove a book from sale if it creates a poor customer experience. The title, cover art and description must not be meant to mislead. If a title is removed, KDP notifies you and you can appeal.
Start with the free checklist
The checklist is the 12 steps I follow for every book I publish, from choosing a topic that already sells to setting up the book's marketing. It is free, and you get it straight away.
You get the free checklist and Chris's emails. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy
Not sure yet? Book a free 25-minute call
Newest posts
- IngramSpark Standard vs Premium Color: Which Interior for Your Book?
- Which AI Should You Use to Write and Self-Publish a Book?
- What Can I Do Before My Manuscript Is Finished? Five Jobs to Start Now
- How Should I Title My Book's Chapters?
- Atticus or Reedsy Studio: Which Should You Use to Format Your Book?
Popular guides
- Lulu Self-Publishing Review 2026: Pros, Cons and Costs
- IngramSpark Review 2026: Free Setup, New Fees and Is It Worth It?
- Is Pegasus a Vanity Publisher? (2026 Update)
- Can You Sell Self Published Books On Etsy?
- How To Edit Your Books For Free With Grammarly
- Self Publishing Lulu VS Blurb?
- 5 Best Self Publishing Courses for Beginners (2026)
- How Long Should A Self-Published Book Be
- What Are The Minimum Amount Of Words For Paperback Books?
- Comparing Ingramspark, Lulu, and KDP Print
- How Many Books Do Self Published Authors Sell?
- Self-Publish For Under $199!



