Book a free 25-minute call. Tell me where your book is now.
Table of Contents
Of the three types of publishing, I recommend self-publishing to almost every author. The other two are hybrid publishing, where you pay a company up front to publish your book, and traditional publishing, where a publisher pays you an advance and takes over the book. Below are the pros and cons of each and how I would choose.
| Topic | Self-publishing | Hybrid publishing | Traditional publishing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who pays | You | You, up front | The publisher pays you an advance |
| Creative control | All yours | Limited | Little or none |
| Time to market | Days | Varies | Often 12 to 18 months or longer |
| Royalties | Highest (KDP: 70% on ebooks priced $2.99 to $12.99) | Can be shared with the company | About 7.5% to 15% of list price on print, 25% of net on ebooks (Authors Guild) |
| Bookstore distribution | You arrange it | Often included | Yes, not a guarantee of sales |
What are the three types of publishing?
They are self-publishing, hybrid publishing and traditional publishing. The quickest way to tell them apart is to ask who pays.
With self-publishing, you are the publisher. You don’t have to do every job yourself, but you have to find the people who do them (cover, editing, formatting) and pay them.
With hybrid publishing, you pay a company up front and it finds the people and runs the book through its system. You lose some flexibility, and some hybrids also take a share of your royalties.
With traditional publishing, the publisher pays you an advance and handles editing, the cover and getting the book into stores. You earn lower royalties, but a lot of people see it as the more respectable route.
What is self-publishing and what are its pros and cons?
Self-publishing means you put the book out under your own account, on Amazon KDP and other platforms, and you keep control and most of the money. It is the route I recommend to almost everyone I coach. For a shorter look at the trade-offs, see what are the self publishing pros and cons?
Advantages of Self-Publishing
The first advantage is complete creative control. Nobody tells you what title or cover to use. You can do what you want as long as it is within what Amazon and the other platforms allow. That can be a bad thing as well as a good thing, but I like it, and the big houses sometimes make choices that are not the best for a book’s sales.
The second is the highest royalties. On Amazon.com, KDP pays 70% on ebooks priced from $2.99 to $12.99 (that band took effect on 07-Jul-26), and on paperbacks it pays 50% or 60% of the list price, depending on the price, minus the printing cost.
The third is speed. You can finish a book and upload it the same day, and in my experience Amazon has it live within a few days (check KDP for its current review time). I have tested how fast you can get through each stage of a book project, and self-publishing is by far the quickest.
Disadvantages of Self-Publishing
The first is the cost up front. Nobody gives you an advance, so you pay for the cover, editing and formatting yourself. Formatting is one job you can learn and stop paying for. I use Atticus for it, though it still takes some time to learn.
The second is distribution and marketing. They depend on how much you are willing to do, and there is a lot to learn. With the other two routes more of it happens without you thinking about it.
The third is the stigma. Some people say anybody can self-publish a book. In my experience that isn’t true. Most people who want to publish a book never get one on the market, because the steps get too confusing. That is what I help with in coaching: we go step by step, and if you don’t give up, the book gets on the market in the best shape you can make it. That doesn’t mean it will sell a million copies, and your second book will be better than the first.
You may lose a little credibility, but you can make a lot more money. Unless you are already famous, self-publishing is the best place to start, and you can always move to another route later.
What is hybrid publishing and what are its pros and cons?
Hybrid publishing is where you pay a company to produce and publish your book, and it may also share your royalties. It can be tricky. Some people call these companies vanity publishers, and the line between the two can be thin. I go through the warning signs in red flags with hybrid publishing companies.
Advantages of Hybrid Publishing
The first is that you don’t have to figure everything out. They have a machine. They know what has to be done, they run the book through it, get it in the right format and often publish it under their own account, so you don’t even set one up.
The second is shared risk. Depending on the deal, the company may take a share of your royalties instead of charging you the full cost up front. But if they share the royalties, the book sits in their account and they own part of the income from it.
The third is distribution and credibility. Many of these companies look very professional, with their own imprint and hundreds or thousands of books behind it. You can find the same distribution and marketing channels yourself. It is just more work.
Disadvantages of Hybrid Publishing
The first is cost. You don’t get any of this for free, and the price varies a lot from one company to the next, so get the full price in writing before you sign. It will almost always cost you more than self-publishing.
The second is limited control. They know how the book has to look to get through their system. In my clients’ experience, if you want changes during the process, extra charges come in, and they add up.
The third is an unclear royalty structure. It isn’t always clear who gets which royalties. If the book is under their account, you can’t see whether sales are coming in, and some charge you a management fee just to report sales to you. You may own the rights, but the royalties can still be split with them, and some authors find it hard to get their book taken down from that account later.
Writer Beware, which is sponsored by the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers Association, has a line for companies that ask for a large sum up front as a condition of publication: “Pay to play is pay to play.”
My rule of thumb for any hybrid publisher: find at least one author, someone you know or someone you can find online, who has done two books with them and was happy with both. Not one book. I have met a lot of people in the middle of the process who were very happy, because everything goes smoothly while they are still paying. At the end, when they want changes, the extra costs come in. Then the book doesn’t sell, and they are offered an expensive marketing package that usually doesn’t earn its money back. Most of those authors do not do a second book with that company.
If you can’t find anyone who was happy with two books, that is a red flag. I have also had clients who were thrilled that their book “got selected” by a hybrid publisher, and found out later that everybody gets selected. There is more on this in why hybrid publishing is wrong for most authors.
What is traditional publishing and what are its pros and cons?
Traditional publishing is where a publisher buys the right to publish your book, pays you an advance and royalties, and does the work. If you are paying money up front, it is not a traditional publisher.
The “Big-5” Publishers
The big five houses are Penguin Random House, Hachette Book Group, HarperCollins, Macmillan Publishers and Simon & Schuster. Everybody in the business knows these names, and a book with one of them says a lot for you.
Other Major Book Publishers
Below them are other large publishers such as Scholastic, Bloomsbury, W. W. Norton, Oxford University Press and Cambridge University Press, plus academic and education publishers.
Mid-Level Book Publishers
Then there are mid-size and independent publishers, for example Sourcebooks in Illinois (fiction, non-fiction and children’s books), Entangled Publishing (romance and young adult) and Graywolf Press, a nonprofit press in Minnesota known for literary fiction, poetry and non-fiction. So it isn’t only the big five.
Advantages of Traditional Publishing
The first is credibility and prestige. It is still seen as the most prestigious route. That said, self-published books get a decent level of respect too, because most people have never published a book at all.
The second is wider distribution. Traditional publishers have a big network that can get your book into major bookstores. That doesn’t guarantee sales. Even Penguin Random House doesn’t know which books will sell, and a book that doesn’t sell early often gets little more attention.
The third is marketing support. If you are one of their big authors, they put a lot behind your book. If you are not, the support is limited and the marketing is still up to you. Many authors think the publisher will market the book for them, and that is a mistake. If the book doesn’t sell, it may be the last one you do with that publisher, and you won’t have built the audience or the skills you would get from self-publishing.
Disadvantages of Traditional Publishing
The first is a lack of creative control. Unless you are famous, you take the title and cover they choose and the changes their editors ask for, or they won’t publish the book. Once you send the manuscript, they decide.
The second is the long process. From what I have seen, it takes 12 to 18 months or longer to get the book out, after you have already waited to be accepted, and sometimes they sit on a project and don’t release it at all. Self-publishing takes a few days once you know the steps. Many traditionally published authors I know were not happy with the result and only did it once, to be able to say they had.
The third is lower royalties. The Authors Guild’s model contract has 10% of the list price on the first 5,000 hardcovers, rising to 15% after 10,000, 7.5% of list on a trade paperback and 25% of net receipts on ebooks, and it notes these are close to what publishers pay now. Compare that with 70% on a KDP ebook. I would not go after a traditional deal until you have proven sales and an audience as a self-publisher. Then you can negotiate better terms instead of taking crumbs, and you can read how the two compare in traditional vs self-publishing.
Which type of publishing should I choose?
For almost every author, self-publishing. You learn how publishing works, you keep control and you earn the most per book. Hybrid or traditional publishing may suit you if you have money to spend and don’t care about sales, or if you are already famous. If you want help choosing your route, book a free 25-minute discovery call.
Frequently asked questions
What are the three types of publishing?
Self-publishing, hybrid publishing and traditional publishing. The quickest way to tell them apart is to ask who pays.
Which type of publishing do you recommend?
Self-publishing, for almost every author. You learn how publishing works, you keep control and you earn the most per book.
What is hybrid publishing?
You pay a company to produce and publish your book, and it may also share your royalties. Get the full price in writing before you sign, and look for an author who did two books with the company and was happy with both.
What do traditional publishers pay?
The Authors Guild model contract gives 10% of list price on the first 5,000 hardcovers, 7.5% of list on a trade paperback and 25% of net receipts on ebooks. Self-publishing on KDP pays 70% on ebooks priced $2.99 to $12.99.
How long does traditional publishing take?
From what I have seen, 12 to 18 months or longer to get the book out, after you have already waited to be accepted. Self-publishing takes a few days once you know the steps.

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird
Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.
Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.
Newest posts
- IngramSpark Standard vs Premium Color: Which Interior for Your Book?
- Which AI Should You Use to Write and Self-Publish a Book?
- What Can I Do Before My Manuscript Is Finished? Five Jobs to Start Now
- How Should I Title My Book's Chapters?
- Atticus or Reedsy Studio: Which Should You Use to Format Your Book?
Popular guides
- Lulu Self-Publishing Review 2026: Pros, Cons and Costs
- IngramSpark Review 2026: Free Setup, New Fees and Is It Worth It?
- Is Pegasus a Vanity Publisher? (2026 Update)
- Can You Sell Self Published Books On Etsy?
- How To Edit Your Books For Free With Grammarly
- Self Publishing Lulu VS Blurb?
- 5 Best Self Publishing Courses for Beginners (2026)
- How Long Should A Self-Published Book Be
- What Are The Minimum Amount Of Words For Paperback Books?
- Comparing Ingramspark, Lulu, and KDP Print
- How Many Books Do Self Published Authors Sell?
- Self-Publish For Under $199!

