Get the free publisher check: the questions to ask before you pay a publishing company.
Table of Contents
Self-publishing is the better choice for most authors. You keep control of the content, design, price, marketing and sales data, and you pay only for the services you pick. A vanity publisher charges you up front, often publishes under its own account, and keeps the sales numbers. The simplest test: if you pay them, it is vanity or hybrid, however they describe it.
What is self-publishing?
You finish the book and then do all the steps, though not necessarily yourself. You may outsource formatting, cover and editing. You coordinate the services, choose the tools, decide the title, order ISBNs, run ads and set up your accounts. That is flexibility, and also work.
What is vanity publishing?
You write the book, and the publisher puts it together: cover, blurb, keywords, maybe editing and marketing. Unlike a traditional publisher, you pay up front, and you may keep paying after the book is made. Some call it hybrid publishing. It is a misnomer, since there is nothing vain about wanting your book on the market, but the pay-to-play model is the same. Writer Beware, which warns authors about publishing scams, wrote on 16-Oct-26 about Starfish Bay Publishing, which asked authors for a “temporary loan”: “Pay to play is pay to play.” Read what is a vanity publisher? and why hybrid publishing is wrong for most authors.
How do self-publishing and vanity publishing compare?
| Topic | Self-publishing | Vanity or hybrid publishing |
|---|---|---|
| Who pays | You, for each service you choose | You, for a package up front |
| Control | You decide content, design, price and marketing | Their template and their schedule |
| Changes | You edit the file yourself | Often a fee per change (one author was quoted about $100) |
| Account | Your own KDP account, your sales dashboard | Often under their account, with reports sent every few months |
| Pricing | You change the price when you like | They may set it and charge to change it |
| Risk | Burnout from learning the tools | Spending thousands before you see sales |
How do I test a vanity publisher?
Ask: am I paying them? Many say they chose your book out of many. Then they want thousands of dollars. My test for any publisher: ask to speak to an author who has done two books with that same company. I have never found one. Where are their Facebook groups and sites where authors share good experiences? I can’t find them. People who did one book tell me it was expensive, they were upsold, the book made no sales, and the publisher had control. I don’t name companies, but a couple of red flags: they say they chose you when the publisher chooses everyone, and nobody can vouch for a second book.
Who controls the book?
As a self-publisher you control content, design, distribution and marketing. With a vanity route, you lose a lot of that. They put your book through a cookie cutter, so it looks like their other books, and each change costs money.
What are the risks of each?
Vanity: spending a lot quickly, then being sold a thousand or five thousand dollar marketing package that probably won’t earn it back. Self-publishing: burning out while you learn the tools. If you have no time, energy or technical knowledge, don’t self-publish. It is a slow climb of book after book, ads and content marketing, with the occasional lottery winner.
Who owns the book and the account?
This matters most. Many vanity publishers publish your book under their own KDP account. Then you can’t see sales on a dashboard or link ads to sales, and you depend on them for numbers, which in my authors’ experience arrive every three months, with fees to get them. If you want the book back, you may lose the reviews. If the company goes bankrupt, what happens to its KDP accounts? KDP’s help page says free KDP ISBNs can only be used on KDP, and with your own ISBN you can list your own imprint. I would use your own publishing-company name, not your own name. Read where to get an ISBN.
What about stocking and selling?
Print on demand means no garage full of books. If you control the account, you can order discounted author copies and change the price when you like. Under a vanity publisher’s account they set the price and may charge for every change.
Which should I choose?
If you want everything done for you, have the cash and are happy with how they do it, vanity publishing may suit you. My problem is that with several books, changes and marketing, thousands go out and the profit disappears, and everything sits under their account. That is why I don’t recommend it. I’m not saying there is anything wrong with vanity or hybrid publishing, but speak to someone who did at least two books with that exact company before you pay, no matter how much money you have.
With self-publishing you get mastery and control, and you can keep up with what Amazon KDP is doing. Take your time with the first book. Don’t press yourself to publish 100 books by Christmas. One book at a time, learn the process, and you won’t depend on others for the changes you want to make. For one author’s experience with a hybrid company, read self-publishing: the best option for you?.
If a company is asking you to pay, my free earnings calculator has a column for a fee and a royalty typed from their offer, so you can see how many copies it takes to get the fee back.
Which route is right for you? If you’ve used a vanity publisher, tell me your experience in the comments. If you have an offer in front of you and want a second opinion, book a free 25-minute discovery call before you pay anything.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between self-publishing and vanity publishing?
In self-publishing you control the content, design, price, marketing and sales data, and you pay only for the services you pick. A vanity publisher charges you up front, often publishes under its own account and keeps the sales numbers.
How can I tell if a publisher is a vanity publisher?
Ask whether you are paying them. If you pay, it is vanity or hybrid, however they describe it. Also ask to speak to an author who has done two books with that same company.
Who owns the KDP account in vanity publishing?
Many vanity publishers publish your book under their own KDP account. Then you cannot see sales on a dashboard, and reports may arrive only every few months, sometimes with fees.
What are the risks of each route?
With a vanity route you can spend thousands before you see sales. With self-publishing the main risk is burnout while you learn the tools.

Free 25-minute self-publishing call with Chris Baird
Tell me where your book is now. You leave the call with a clear next step for publishing it.
Free, 25 minutes on Zoom, no card needed.
Newest posts
- IngramSpark Standard vs Premium Color: Which Interior for Your Book?
- Which AI Should You Use to Write and Self-Publish a Book?
- What Can I Do Before My Manuscript Is Finished? Five Jobs to Start Now
- How Should I Title My Book's Chapters?
- Atticus or Reedsy Studio: Which Should You Use to Format Your Book?
Popular guides
- Lulu Self-Publishing Review 2026: Pros, Cons and Costs
- IngramSpark Review 2026: Free Setup, New Fees and Is It Worth It?
- Is Pegasus a Vanity Publisher? (2026 Update)
- Can You Sell Self Published Books On Etsy?
- How To Edit Your Books For Free With Grammarly
- Self Publishing Lulu VS Blurb?
- 5 Best Self Publishing Courses for Beginners (2026)
- How Long Should A Self-Published Book Be
- What Are The Minimum Amount Of Words For Paperback Books?
- Comparing Ingramspark, Lulu, and KDP Print
- How Many Books Do Self Published Authors Sell?
- Self-Publish For Under $199!

